
Prison stabbing claim dismissed despite error releasing attacker from cell
The B.C. Supreme Court found that an unchecked appointment claim enabled the attack, but the harm was not reasonably foreseeable.
Section
Supreme Court of British Columbia decisions and developments
30 stories
The B.C. Supreme Court found that an unchecked appointment claim enabled the attack, but the harm was not reasonably foreseeable.

A shareholder failed to prove rights to corporate assets or sale proceeds, but obtained an order requiring financial statements.

Mixed success, trust-fund use and a rejected walk-away offer leave each party bearing their own costs.

Joint decision-making remains in place, while travel requires notice and regular contact with the non-travelling parent.

The client records Ventum sought could help establish whether business was diverted and what it lost. A challenge to a non-compete clause would leave other claims to resolve.

Company-paid personal expenses increased the construction owner’s support income. Broader assumptions about business spending were left for trial, and earlier support remains…

Avonlea accepted shares after a merger missed its deadline. The court ordered the investor to keep its side of the bargain and end a separate oppression petition.

The court accepts a joint recommendation, emphasizing intimate partner violence, high moral responsibility and the limits of rehabilitation as a mitigating consideration.

The township was still seeking voluntary compliance with its noise bylaw when its lawyers hired an expert. A B.C. judge found the records were protected by litigation privilege.

A key witness had died and financial records remained missing in a dispute that turned on whether a couple had lived together for two years.

The court upheld the available defences and separately found that protecting public debate outweighed the demonstrated harm. Full-indemnity costs remain subject to submissions.

The court balanced denunciation and deterrence with Indigenous background factors, finding supervised reintegration necessary to protect the community from repeated violence.

A Pemberton event rental company alleges that Google’s payments for default placement kept Apple out of the search market and drove up ad prices. The court found a workable way to…

Consumers can pursue their claim that meatpackers’ cattle purchases drove up beef prices. U.S. investigative demands offered too little to support a separate allegation about how…

The joint expert must value both trust-held companies and Van Kolias’s beneficial interest. The court limited the assignment to fair market value.

The driver had already brought the city into the case. The plaintiff sought to sue it directly after her lawyers noticed the driver’s $200,000 insurance limit.

The court allowed clarifications to existing contract claims but refused amendments that would reopen the share sale and substantially expand the litigation.

B.C. court finds a rare potential duty to a represented non-client warrants trial; negligence, fraud and damages have not been finally decided.

Claims against two defendants were struck with leave to amend, while unjust enrichment remains. The court made no findings of fraud or conspiracy.

Construction had continued despite earlier warnings of a stoppage. The judge also allowed the school to expand its claims over the North Vancouver project.