
A settlement gave Avonlea Ventures and its director seven million additional energy-company shares. Avonlea left its shareholder oppression petition open after the written deal expired. In Avonlea Ventures #2 Inc. v Current Energy and Renewables Holding Corp., the B.C. Supreme Court ordered Avonlea to discontinue the petition. The parties had made a second agreement through the way they handled the delayed merger, delivered the shares and accepted them.
The dispute dated back to an investment by Avonlea and its director, Michael Steele. In 2020, Avonlea brought an oppression petition against Current Energy and Renewables Corp. and David Coburn. Current wanted to put the dispute behind it before combining with ARMM Inc., an American public company. The April 27, 2023 settlement called for five million new Current shares for Steele and two million for Avonlea. Those shares would be exchanged for ARMM shares in the merger.
What the parties did after the deadline
Current issued the settlement shares, but the merger missed its May 26 closing date. Everyone eventually agreed that the written contract expired the next day under its own terms. At the time, however, counsel for the two sides agreed to more time. The merger closed on June 2. Later that month, Steele supplied signed registration documents so the new company could register the plaintiffs’ shares.
When the certificates still had not arrived in August, Avonlea threatened to proceed with the petition. On September 5, the parties agreed to allow until October 6 for delivery. Avonlea and Steele accepted proof of their shares on September 27, around the same time as the other Current shareholders. Their lawyers subsequently sought financial information and pressed for a shareholders’ meeting to elect directors.
Avonlea and Steele later sued Current Energy and Renewables Holding Corp., a subsidiary of Current, and Coburn for breach of the written settlement. At the summary trial, the plaintiffs conceded the defendants had not breached that agreement and abandoned their claim. That left the defendants’ counterclaim to enforce the bargain.
What made the second agreement binding
Avonlea and Steele argued that nobody could say when a new agreement had been made, when the merger had to close or when the petition had to be withdrawn. Justice J. Hughes found the correspondence showed agreement by September 5 at the latest. The parties understood the revised merger and delivery dates. Withdrawal would follow receipt of the correct shares on the same basis as other shareholders. That sequence gave the obligation a clear meaning even without a separate calendar date for filing.
The plaintiffs also argued that as existing shareholders they were already entitled to ARMM shares, so they had received nothing new in exchange for the promise to discontinue. Hughes distinguished the shares they had earned on their original investment from the additional seven million they held only because of the settlement. Keeping those additional shares and receiving their ARMM equivalents supplied the necessary consideration.
In June 2026 the plaintiffs offered to return the ARMM shares. By then they had concluded the shares were worthless. The evidence did not establish their value, and the judge assessed the bargain by what the parties exchanged at the time. The later offer did not undo their breach.
Why the court ordered discontinuance
Hughes found no workable way to calculate damages for leaving the petition outstanding. A judgment on the counterclaim would not itself end the petition because it was a separate proceeding. Hughes also saw a reason to protect the incentive to settle. Refusing to enforce the promise would leave the plaintiffs with the extra shares and let Avonlea pursue the very petition it had agreed to drop. The court dismissed the remaining relief, including a claim for unjust enrichment that the defendants did not pursue. The defendants were presumptively entitled to costs of the application and action, with 30 days for either side to request a further hearing on costs.



