
The British Columbia Supreme Court has ordered a construction-company owner to pay interim child and spousal support, along with a $5,000 penalty for financial disclosure failures. But the judge rejected his former spouse’s much higher income estimates, finding that the proposed adjustments relied on assumptions better tested at trial.
In Tsai v Tsai, 2026 BCSC 2200, Justice Blok set Peter Tsai’s income for support purposes at $126,000 for 2024 through 2026. The November 13 ruling requires monthly child support of $1,184 and spousal support of $878 from January 2026, with higher spousal support for part of 2025. The parties may seek revised interim amounts once he completes disclosure and files an updated financial statement.
Support while the financial dispute continues
Olivia and Peter Tsai separated in February 2023 and have one child. Olivia had not worked outside the home during the relationship. After separation, she retrained and began working as a legal assistant in May 2025, earning approximately $50,000 annually.
Peter owned and operated a construction company. His income was contested, and his only sworn financial statement dated from February 2024. Olivia said corporate expenses, cash deposits and rental activity showed substantially more income available for support than he reported. Peter disputed her calculations and said the requested payments exceeded his ability to pay.
The court refused a further adjournment. Support already being paid appeared substantially below the appropriate amount, and an interim hearing was not the place for the exhaustive financial analysis Peter wanted. The judge instead preserved the opportunity to revisit the amounts after proper disclosure.
Blok also found a preliminary basis for spousal-support entitlement. Olivia’s time out of the workforce, retraining and continuing responsibility for most child care placed her at a relationship-related disadvantage while Peter’s career continued. Her subsequent employment did not eliminate that basis for interim support.
Why the larger income estimates were rejected
Olivia proposed incomes of approximately $245,000 for 2023, $366,500 for 2024 and $376,800 for 2025. Her calculations added assumed unreported cash income and treated 25 per cent of the company’s non-salary expenses as personal benefits, with adjustments for their untaxed character.
She pointed to unexplained or apparently personal entries in the corporate ledger, incomplete records and changing rental expenses. She also tried to reconstruct 2025 rental income using deposits and assumptions about expenses because Peter had not supplied a 2025 tax return.
Blok found that reconstruction unreliable and preferred the last available tax return as a benchmark. He likewise refused to assume that all cash deposits represented unreported income or that a quarter of every non-salary business expense benefited Peter personally.
The court acknowledged the difficulty created by Peter’s disclosure failures and opaque financial arrangements. It also recognized that many of his explanations were not supported by affidavit evidence. The judge did not treat those assertions as proven facts. Instead, he considered them only when assessing whether Olivia’s proposed inferences were reasonable.
Some explanations were plausible enough to require testing: short-term rentals may carry greater cleaning costs, an out-of-town construction project may increase crew travel expenses, and replacing employees with subcontractors may change the company’s expense profile. Those questions required discovery and, if necessary, trial rather than broad assumptions at an interim hearing.
Personal benefits still increased support income
The rejection of Olivia’s methodology did not end the income adjustment. Peter admitted that the company covered some personal expenses, particularly vehicles. The ledger also contained numerous items the judge considered likely personal, including recreational purchases, restaurant charges and other non-business spending.
On the available evidence, Blok found personal benefits of at least $10,000 annually for 2023 through 2025. He grossed that amount up to $15,000 to reflect its untaxed nature. Adding it to reported income produced rounded support incomes of $111,000 for 2023 and $126,000 for 2024 through 2026, using the available figures and assumptions for the later years.
For Olivia, the court used no income in 2023 and 2024, $24,000 in 2025 and $50,000 in 2026. Her counsel suggested $47,000 for 2026, but the judge could not find evidence supporting that lower figure.
Retroactivity and the orders made
Olivia sought support back to March 2023. Blok left the period before April 2025 for trial because Peter had provided credit-card access and a vehicle, and the value of those benefits was disputed. An interim order for that earlier period would leave the net amount owing unresolved.
That was not a finding that support obligations began only in April 2025. The judge expressly said Peter remained obliged to support Olivia and the child from separation. The interim orders simply addressed the later period, when the limited payments already made could be identified.
For April through December 2025, the court ordered monthly child support of $1,184 and spousal support of $1,695. From January 2026, child support remained $1,184 while spousal support fell to $878. Payments are due on the first of each month. Ongoing special or extraordinary child expenses are to be shared proportionately to the parties’ incomes on an interim basis.
The separate $5,000 penalty was payable immediately. Disclosure failures included not producing an ordered list of documents, failing to update the sworn financial statement, incomplete compliance with a January 2026 disclosure order and unanswered or delayed responses to repeated requests.
Olivia also received costs because she was substantially successful despite overstating Peter’s income. Unlike the penalty, those costs were not ordered payable immediately. The judgment did not fix a net arrears total or finally resolve the parties’ financial dispute.
Source: Tsai v Tsai, 2026 BCSC 2200.



