A former half-owner of Northcoast Helicopters cannot add late oppression and unjust-enrichment claims to litigation over his exit from the company, the British Columbia Supreme Court has ruled. The court allowed amendments clarifying existing contractual claims but rejected proposals that would reopen the share sale through a retrospective valuation and substantially expand the lawsuit.

In Northcoast Helicopters Incorporated v Schutte, 2026 BCSC 2177, Associate Judge Krentz found the delay inadequately explained and the proposed new claims inappropriate. The October 30 ruling did not decide whether money was owing under the parties’ original arrangements or whether their releases were binding.

A buyout followed by disputed debts

Craig Roy and Schutte operated Northcoast as equal owners after working together to obtain Transport Canada operating certification. They had no written shareholder agreement. The company leased a helicopter, with both owners providing collateral.

Their 2020 buyout discussions led to a share purchase agreement and releases. Schutte transferred his shares to Roy’s spouse, Kristen Rock. The arrangements also addressed operating capital, equipment and an application to remove Schutte’s personal guarantee from the helicopter lease.

Northcoast and Roy later sued, alleging that Schutte owed the company $372,000 in shareholder loans, had misrepresented liabilities and had wrongfully retained a truck and trailer. Schutte denied that repayable loans existed and said any such amounts had been accounted for in the negotiations.

His original counterclaim sought relief including correction of the release, damages and costs. The plaintiffs disputed the alleged breach and denied that the company was a party to the release or that rectification was available.

Schutte’s discovery evidence described shared financial records tracking the owners’ withdrawals. He said the buyout already accounted for any money he owed the company. Discovery also produced disputes about the releases and the parties’ knowledge of the financial information. Those underlying disagreements remained for the litigation to resolve.

New remedies sought years later

Schutte sought to add alternative claims designed to prevent what he characterized as double recovery: the plaintiffs retaining the benefit of his shares and work while also recovering alleged loans. He proposed an independent valuation of his former shares, a purchase at fair market value and a set-off for any loans found owing. He also sought relief for unpaid services, aggravated and punitive damages and other compensation.

He said earlier counsel had failed to frame his pleadings properly and that the need for amendments became apparent after he changed lawyers in fall 2025. An application was prepared in February 2026 but, because of scheduling conflicts and court availability, was heard in July and October. A February trial had been adjourned without a new date.

The plaintiffs accepted changes clarifying the existing contract and rectification claims. They opposed the new claims, arguing that Schutte had known the underlying facts since 2020 or, at the latest, their 2022 pleadings. They said the expansion would require more disclosure, discoveries, accounting and valuation evidence after the limitation period had expired.

Why oppression and unjust enrichment were different

Krentz considered whether allowing new claims despite an accrued limitation defence would be just and convenient, including the delay and prejudice to the opposing parties. The court found the application came well after expiry of the limitation period. A change of counsel in 2025 did not satisfactorily explain why claims based on facts known by 2022 had not been pleaded earlier.

The oppression claim had additional defects. Krentz accepted that a former shareholder can bring such a claim. But Schutte had not pleaded sufficient material facts to show he was an appropriate person to seek this relief in 2026. His proposal sought to reopen a completed sale and recast existing contract, release and set-off issues, rather than address continuing corporate unfairness.

The requested remedy also contemplated valuing and purchasing shares Schutte no longer owned. It would introduce new valuation and accounting questions into a case not pleaded as a valuation proceeding. The court emphasized that oppression relief must be pursued in time to correct an existing wrong.

Unjust enrichment was likewise a distinct new claim. It was not needed to guard against double recovery: the accepted amendments already allowed Schutte to argue that the parties made a binding agreement and to pursue existing positions concerning breach of contract, releases, rectification, loan forgiveness, withdrawals and set-offs.

Although courts generally take a generous approach to amendments as litigation develops, Krentz found these proposals changed the substance of the dispute rather than naturally refining it.

The court refused the new oppression, unjust-enrichment, unpaid-services, retrospective-valuation, aggravated-damages, punitive-damages and litigation-prejudice compensation claims. The remaining amendments were allowed. Costs of the application were awarded to the plaintiffs in the cause, tying them to the eventual outcome of the proceeding.

Source: Northcoast Helicopters Incorporated v Schutte, 2026 BCSC 2177.