
The British Columbia Supreme Court has dismissed an inmate’s negligence claim over a prison stabbing even though a correctional officer wrongly released the attacker from his cell. The court found that the error enabled the attack, but that the harm to the plaintiff was not reasonably foreseeable.
In Swallow v Canada (Attorney General), 2026 BCSC 2214, Justice Loo dismissed Nolan Swallow’s action against the federal government following a summary trial on liability. The November 16 ruling also rejected a separate allegation that officers should have intervened when the attacker waited near a corridor.
The distinction was between a breach of the standard of care that factually contributed to an injury and one that legally justified liability. The court found the first, but not the second, in the decision to open the cell.
An unchecked appointment claim preceded the attack
Swallow was an inmate at Matsqui Institution, a medium-security federal penitentiary in Abbotsford. On November 14, 2016, he was paged to report to admissions and discharge for release on day parole.
Shortly afterwards, Dennis Fletcher told an officer he needed to leave his cell for a counselling appointment. That was false. The officer released him without checking whether an appointment existed. Fletcher waited near a corridor on Swallow’s route and stabbed him as he passed. An officer gave orders to stop, and Swallow received medical care and was taken to hospital.
Both sides agreed to have liability determined by summary trial ahead of a full trial scheduled for December 7, 2026. They had exchanged documents, conducted examinations for discovery and agreed on facts. Loo found the record sufficient to decide the issues fairly.
The federal government conceded that the Correctional Service of Canada owed Swallow a duty to take reasonable care for his safety. The standard required reasonable protection against foreseeable risks, rather than a guarantee that no inmate would be harmed.
Loo found that failing to verify Fletcher’s appointment breached that standard. It also satisfied factual causation: without the error, Fletcher could not have committed the stabbing, at least at that time. The remaining question was whether the harm was too remote to make the government legally responsible.
Four arguments did not establish foreseeability
Swallow first relied on both men’s histories of violence. Loo noted, however, that neither had disciplinary issues involving violence while at Matsqui. Their recent institutional histories did not make this attack reasonably foreseeable, and no authority established a duty to prevent encounters between violent inmates who had no known connection to each other.
Second, Swallow pointed to an attack against him by another inmate five months earlier. A criminology expert considered that incident a risk factor suggesting that whoever was responsible might try again. But the earlier assailant had been transferred to another institution, and there was no indication that staff knew of any connection between that person and Fletcher.
There had been no reported concerns about further violence against Swallow in the intervening period. He had not expressed safety concerns to officers. His previous interactions with Fletcher had been cordial, without threats or disagreements.
Third, Swallow argued that his withdrawal from illicit activities and increased participation in correctional programming could have made other inmates view him as an informant. The expert identified that general risk, but the court found no evidence that officers knew or should have known Swallow was perceived that way. He conceded that no inmate had threatened him for distancing himself from former associates.
Fourth, Swallow said the public announcement of his departure could have signalled a last opportunity to attack him. Fletcher’s request to leave his cell followed the announcement, and the men would be near the same area. Loo found the timing meaningful only in hindsight, assuming a motive to harm Swallow that staff had no reason to suspect. Paging inmates was routine, and inmates used false pretexts to leave cells for many reasons.
The court distinguished earlier cases involving known warning signs or a systemic security gap. Swallow did not allege such a systemic flaw, and Fletcher had not been identified as incompatible with him.
The corridor allegation failed on separate grounds
Swallow also argued that officers should have noticed Fletcher waiting near the corridor and intervened. But there was no evidence that either relevant officer actually saw him before the attack. The record did not establish that failing to notice him fell below the standard of care.
Nor was there evidence from the expert or assistant warden establishing what an officer had to do upon seeing someone waiting in that area. Fletcher was there for about 90 seconds before the attack.
Loo therefore found no breach on this branch of the claim. Independently, even if there had been a breach, the court would have rejected liability because the harm was not reasonably foreseeable: Fletcher could have been waiting for many reasons, and officers had no reason to suspect hostility between the men.
The action was dismissed. The ruling did not award damages for the injuries or turn the acknowledged error in releasing Fletcher into legal liability for the stabbing.
Source: Swallow v Canada (Attorney General), 2026 BCSC 2214.



