A woman who sued a driver over a collision cannot add the City of Burnaby as a defendant more than five years after the crash. The driver had already brought Burnaby into the case over foliage she said obstructed a stop sign. What prompted the plaintiff to seek a direct claim against the city was the driver’s $200,000 insurance limit and a concern about collecting any judgment above it.

In Thompson v Cromwell, B.C. Supreme Court Associate Judge Robinson found that the plaintiff had long had the information she needed to decide whom to sue. The city remains a third party, answerable to the driver if the driver establishes her claim against it. The November 2 ruling left responsibility for the collision and the plaintiff’s entitlement to insurance benefits unresolved.

What changed after Burnaby joined the case

Carol-Ann Thompson alleges that Amber Cromwell failed to stop at a stop sign in April 2021 and that Thompson was injured as a result. When Thompson sued in November 2022, she named Cromwell alone. Her lawyers expected Cromwell to bear most or all of the fault. They considered that, because they saw no basis for attributing fault to Thompson, she could recover the full judgment from Cromwell even if someone else shared responsibility.

Cromwell disclosed her liability coverage in July 2023 and listed photographs of the sign that November. In January 2024 she obtained leave to bring a third-party claim alleging that Burnaby had failed to keep the sign visible. The city denied liability. Thompson’s lawyers said they realized only in September 2026 that Cromwell’s policy limit was $200,000. They anticipated that ICBC would withhold the consent they believed Thompson needed to preserve access to underinsured motorist benefits unless she sued the city directly.

Robinson examined two ways to add a defendant under the Supreme Court Civil Rules. The first addresses a defect in the existing proceedings, such as the absence of a party necessary to decide the issues fully. Thompson had been content for years to have liability and damages decided without a direct claim against Burnaby. Her concern about a potential benefit from her own insurer did not establish that the city had to be a defendant for those issues to be decided.

Why the delay mattered even on Thompson’s timeline

The second route allows the court to hear a connected claim where doing so would be just and convenient. Burnaby conceded that the proposed pleading about the sign raised a real issue. That left the delay, the explanation for it and the effects of adding the city after the limitation period.

Robinson found the condition of the intersection had been open to inspection from the outset. Even if the insurance limit was decisive, Cromwell had disclosed it more than three years before the application. Counsel described overlooking the information, but no affidavit explained the oversight. Even measuring only from January 2024, when Cromwell obtained permission to proceed against the city, Thompson had waited 32 months. Robinson found the unexplained delay sufficient on its own to refuse the application.

Thompson relied on an earlier B.C. decision allowing a plaintiff to add parties to preserve a right to recover from them. In that case the plaintiff acted five months after they became third parties, and they already faced a related action to be tried at the same time. Thompson’s stated purpose was to preserve a potential insurance recovery from someone outside the lawsuit. Robinson found that distinction and the much longer wait significant.

The judge also considered what each side stood to lose. Adding Burnaby 41 months after the limitation period expired would deprive it of a complete defence to Thompson’s claim. Until then, its exposure depended on Thompson first establishing liability against Cromwell. A direct claim could require a different litigation strategy. Thompson’s lawyers, meanwhile, had themselves regarded the claim against the city as relatively weak. The risk that a defendant might lack the means to satisfy a judgment was present from the beginning.

Robinson dismissed Thompson’s application and awarded Burnaby its costs of the application, assessable at Scale B regardless of the outcome of the underlying lawsuit.

Read the B.C. Supreme Court’s reasons, 2026 BCSC 2202.