
Canadian advertisers can pursue a class action against Apple over the price of ads they bought from Google. In Spark Event Rentals Ltd. v Apple Inc., the B.C. Supreme Court certified a claim alleging that Google’s payments to remain the default search engine on Apple devices discouraged Apple from competing and allowed Google to charge advertisers more. The advertisers still have to prove that the agreement was unlawful and that it caused a loss.
Spark, an event rental company in Pemberton, bought Google search ads. It represents Canadian residents who, from 2005 onward, purchased ads that Google displayed in response to a general search query. The class definition excludes ads on specialized search engines, such as travel booking sites, and excludes the defendants, their parent companies, subsidiaries and affiliates.
Spark initially sued Google as well. The court stayed that part of the case so an arbitrator could decide whether the dispute fell within the arbitration clause in Spark’s advertising contract. Spark discontinued its claim against Google and did not start arbitration. Apple Inc. and Apple Canada Inc. remained as defendants.
The companies offered different explanations for the default arrangement. Spark alleged that Apple had the resources and distribution network to develop or acquire a rival search engine, but that doing so would put billions of dollars in advertising revenue shared by Google at risk. Apple argued that Google offered the best search product, that other existing search engines were unsuitable and that Apple preferred to devote its resources elsewhere.
Apple said the agreement was an ordinary distribution deal. Spark alleged that the companies had also agreed to keep a potential rival out of the market. That distinction mattered under the Competition Act. A company can count as a competitor if it would likely have entered the market without the challenged agreement. The court found that Spark had pleaded enough facts about Apple’s resources, its access to customers and its share of Google’s ad revenue to take that allegation to trial. Spark also alleged that Canadian subsidiaries put the U.S. arrangement into effect here.
Justice Thomas considered testimony from a U.S. antitrust case against Google in which Apple was not a party. An Apple executive testified that the company had weighed the advantages and disadvantages of building or buying a search engine. The judge found enough evidence to put Spark’s theory to a common trial. Choosing between the competing explanations would require weighing the evidence, a task for the court hearing the merits.
A second question was how advertisers could establish that they paid too much. Spark’s economist proposed comparing the profitability of Google’s Canadian search advertising business with benchmarks reflecting a more competitive market. He would estimate how far prices would have had to fall each year to bring profits down to that level, then apply the estimated overcharge to advertisers’ spending.
Apple questioned whether the proposed comparisons accounted for differences in company size and product quality, and whether the necessary financial data could be obtained from Google. Thomas found a reasonable prospect that the method could estimate an overcharge. Records produced in the U.S. litigation showed that relevant data existed. Whether any advertiser suffered a loss, and whether damages could ultimately be calculated for the group, remain open.
Google’s absence from the lawsuit leaves a practical hurdle for advertisers. Spark may have to use proceedings in the United States to obtain the company’s financial data. The judge accepted that there was a reasonable chance of getting the records and said the action could be decertified if the data proved unavailable and the economist could not carry out his analysis. Even a finding of overcharging would leave the trial judge to determine which advertisers suffered a loss before awarding damages for the group.
Read the B.C. Supreme Court’s certification decision, 2026 BCSC 1971.



