
Alberta appeal court refuses publicly funded lawyer for challenge to remand credit
The panel accepted that Donald Burnett could not afford counsel but found his proposed sentence appeal lacked sufficient merit to justify public funding.
Section
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Crime.
73 stories
The panel accepted that Donald Burnett could not afford counsel but found his proposed sentence appeal lacked sufficient merit to justify public funding.

Three prison-assault appeals failed after the court distinguished knowing the Crown’s case from obtaining advance rulings on possible defences and applied the Supreme Court’s…

The court rejects the Crown’s challenge to a release plan involving house arrest, GPS monitoring and financial security, without deciding guilt or extradition.

A 5–4 decision says a momentary lapse can meet the dangerous-driving fault threshold, with four judges finding no basis to overturn the acquittals.

The appeal panel found the judge acted fairly when he warned the accused about repeated interruptions and asked the prosecutor to explain the warning to the complainant.

Arthur Cook’s aggravated-assault conviction and 24-month custodial sentence stand after the court upheld the trial judge’s assessment of surveillance footage and the force used.

The appeal court rejected a categorical approach to firearms sentencing, finding that the young first offender’s restrictive conditional sentence was not demonstrably unfit.

The court rejected challenges to the assessment of the complainant’s testimony and found that proposed new evidence was too uncertain to justify reopening the case.

The judge found wilful blindness in the accused’s failure to take basic steps to attend, while emphasizing that the test for a legitimate excuse is low and that financial cost was…

The judge found Dennis Rowsell could present his sentence challenge with court and clinic assistance, while leaving its merits undecided.

The appeal court left robbery and confinement convictions intact but found the reasons did not adequately address statements that could raise reasonable doubt about murder.

The court rejected a habeas corpus appeal over the start date of a sentence changed on appeal.

The 7–2 ruling rejects a Charter challenge based on a hypothetical young first offender, while dissenting judges warn that mandatory jail can be grossly disproportionate when a…

The acquittals of five accused were set aside, but outstanding trial-delay applications must be decided before the prosecution can continue.

The unanimous ruling requires police to preserve relevant disciplinary records, leaves disclosure decisions with prosecutors and awards solicitor-client costs against Edmonton’s…

The appeal court found a significant hearsay error but rejected a request for acquittals.

The court restored an Ontario drug prosecution while rejecting a broad discretion to excuse excessive delay. Justice Rowe agreed with the result but urged a wider change to the…

A six-judge majority restored an Ontario prosecution after excluding three weeks caused by a co-accused’s lawyer’s availability. Three dissenters said the Crown had waited too…

An eight-judge majority said a statement used to place the accused alone with the victim depended on its truth, even when described as circumstantial evidence. Justice Côté would…

The unanimous ruling keeps a forfeiture route open after a Charter delay stay, but requires the Crown to prove unlawful possession and leaves the fate of the assets to the Court…