
A British Columbia judge has imposed a 20-month sentence, already covered by credited time in custody, and two years of probation on a man convicted of assaulting and threatening a vulnerable Indigenous woman. The court concluded that community supervision was essential to protect the public and address his repeated violence.
In R v Arnet, 2026 BCSC 2194, Justice Dion rejected the Crown’s request for a substantially longer jail sentence. The November 9 ruling required Justin Arnet to stay away from the victim and a defined part of downtown Campbell River, subject to specified exceptions, and to participate in counselling as directed by his probation officer.
The sentence comprised 18 months for assault, three months concurrently for uttering threats and two months consecutively for obstructing police. The judge recognized 861 days of credit for 574 actual days in custody. The reasons do not establish when Arnet was physically released.
Serious violence against a vulnerable victim
Arnet’s convictions arose from an April 2025 attack on a relative in downtown Campbell River. He believed she had taken his belongings after he suffered an overdose. The judge found that he threatened her, twisted her arm behind her back and kicked her while she was down. Her arm remained painful and difficult to use for about a month.
At trial, Dion acquitted Arnet of robbery because the Crown had not proved an intention to steal, but convicted him of the included offence of assault. The judge also found him guilty of threats and obstruction after he twice fled police. The sentencing ruling dealt with those three convictions, not a robbery conviction from this incident.
The Crown sought a global sentence of three and a half years, less credit, emphasizing denunciation, deterrence and public protection. The defence sought 120 days followed by two years of probation. It also argued that earlier assault cases involved more serious conduct.
Dion rejected the suggestion that the victim had not been frightened or that the attack was comparatively innocuous. The victim was Indigenous, disabled and vulnerable. The violence was gratuitous, and her circumstances required primary attention to denunciation and deterrence.
Arnet’s record and the circumstances of his offending aggravated the sentence. He had previous convictions for manslaughter and robbery and was on probation for the robbery of another vulnerable Indigenous woman when he committed these offences. The judge identified a pattern of violence against marginalized members of the downtown community.
Indigenous background mattered without displacing public protection
The court also considered Arnet’s personal and intergenerational circumstances through an earlier Gladue report, which he chose to rely on instead of obtaining an update. He did not seek an alternative sentencing procedure such as a sentencing circle.
Dion accepted that intergenerational trauma, colonialism, family instability, exposure to violence and substance misuse had affected Arnet’s upbringing, coping skills and judgment. Those factors reduced his moral culpability. They were the mitigating circumstances identified by the court, although the judge still assessed his blameworthiness as high.
The analysis also addressed the effectiveness of the sentence. The judge applied the principle that sentencing must account for Indigenous offenders’ experiences and the limitations of approaches that have failed to respond to their circumstances. At the same time, relying on the Supreme Court of Canada’s guidance in Cope, Dion emphasized that rehabilitation could not take equal or greater priority than denunciation and deterrence where a vulnerable Indigenous woman had been abused.
The court found some evidence of insight and progress. Arnet had taken steps in custody to learn ways of coping without violence and had support that included an offer of employment. But his efforts remained incomplete, and the judge largely agreed that he had failed to restrain his violent impulses.
Why the court chose supervision
Dion found that the Crown’s proposed three-year assault sentence exceeded what was necessary to meet the sentencing objectives, including Arnet’s reduced culpability. The judge also explained that imposing the longer jail sentence proposed by the Crown would remove probation from the available sentencing combination.
Further incarceration followed by release without integrative supervision risked returning Arnet to the community he had repeatedly harmed without the support and accountability needed to change his behaviour. Two years of probation therefore formed a central part of the sentence’s protective purpose.
The conditions included no contact with the victim, staying at least 25 metres away from her and specified places connected with her, approved residence and reporting requirements, and counselling that could address substance use, trauma and anger. Arnet was also ordered to apologize in the manner directed by his probation officer by January 29, 2027.
The downtown exclusion allowed specified exceptions, including scheduled court or community-corrections appointments, travelling through in a moving vehicle and prior permission from the probation officer. The order also contained substance and weapons restrictions, with stated exceptions.
Dion declined additional discretionary DNA and firearms orders, noting an existing DNA order, an existing weapons prohibition and that no weapon had been used in these offences. The victim fine surcharge was waived because of Arnet’s extended time in custody.
Source: R v Arnet, 2026 BCSC 2194.



