A Sudbury judge has refused to stay drug and firearm charges against Ashawn Trench, whose joint jury trial was scheduled to finish more than 39 months after he was charged. Trench was available to stand trial in February 2026, within the usual 30-month ceiling. His co-accused’s lawyer was unavailable, and the next 10-day block the court could offer began in November.

In R. v. Clarke, Justice R.D. Gordon gave two reasons for dismissing Trench’s application. He refused permission to bring it so close to trial. He also worked through the delay itself and concluded that, once the scheduling conflict was accounted for, the time chargeable under the Charter was 29 months. The November 13 ruling left the charges unresolved. Trial was scheduled for November 23 to December 4, 2026.

Three days to answer 87 tabs

When the trial dates were fixed in August 2025, everyone could see that the trial would finish well beyond the presumptive ceiling, Gordon wrote. Yet the defence pretrial report indicated that Trench did not intend to bring a delay application. Several court appearances followed. Trench gave notice of the application in October 2026, nearly 14 months after the dates were set.

Under Ontario’s criminal proceedings rules, the application should have been heard at least 60 days before trial. The applicant’s materials were due 30 days before the hearing. Instead, Trench’s supporting record was effectively served on November 9 for a November 12 hearing. The Crown had three days, including Remembrance Day, to answer several hundred pages in 87 tabs. The defence’s written argument ran to 36 pages against a 20-page limit, without permission to exceed it.

Defence counsel explained that she had overlooked the application amid work and family pressures. Gordon recognized the importance of hearing a Charter claim on its merits. But the short notice impaired the Crown’s ability to respond and cost it a chance to consider moving another case to make room for this one. The judge refused leave.

Why the February trial dates mattered

Even if he had granted leave, Gordon found that the delay did not justify a stay. He calculated 39 months and five days from the August 2023 charges to the scheduled end of trial. Trench was responsible for two weeks because he had failed to file a statement of issues needed to schedule the preliminary hearing. The judge put the remaining delay at 38 months and 20 days, leaving the Crown to justify the excess above 30 months.

The Crown relied on the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in R. v. Jacques-Taylor. Gordon found that trying Trench and Shaquille Clarke together served the interests of justice. They faced the same charges arising from the same warrant and searches of a Sudbury residence and vehicle. The joint trial directly accounted for the lost February dates. The court, Crown and Trench had all been available, and the Crown could not control the defence lawyers’ calendars.

Trench argued that the Crown should have tried him separately in February. That would have required two blocks of court time and witnesses giving evidence twice, with a risk of conflicting findings about the same events. Once Trench gave notice, the Crown could no longer reasonably be expected to rearrange other trials. Gordon treated the nine months and three weeks attributable to the scheduling conflict as an exceptional circumstance and put the adjusted delay at 29 months.

Trench could still have obtained a stay below the ceiling by showing sustained efforts to move the case along and that it had taken markedly longer than it reasonably should. The judge said little of the delay was Trench’s fault but found little evidence that he had pressed for an earlier trial. Scheduling involved four lawyers, including federal and provincial prosecutors, and a three-day preliminary hearing. For more than two years, the case had also proceeded on the understanding that the accused would challenge the searches and arrests. They abandoned those challenges in March 2026. In those circumstances, Gordon found 29 months reasonable.

Read the Ontario Superior Court’s reasons on CanLII.