
The New Brunswick Court of Appeal has upheld convictions for dangerous driving causing death and impaired driving causing death, rejecting arguments that the verdicts lacked adequate evidentiary support. The court found that eyewitness accounts and expert evidence, considered together, supported the trial judge’s conclusions.
In Pellow v. R., 2026 NBCA 128, Justice Green, writing for a unanimous panel, dismissed Kyle Pellow’s conviction appeal on November 12. Pellow had been sentenced to six years in prison. The appeal concerned his convictions, rather than a request to reduce that sentence.
The ruling also distinguished proof of impaired driving from a separate charge based on a specified blood-alcohol concentration. Pellow had been acquitted of that third count at trial; the appeal did not disturb that acquittal.
Witnesses described speed and close driving
Pellow was driving on Route 905 in Pollett River on July 25, 2023, when he lost control and crashed, killing his passenger. Six eyewitnesses, travelling as three unrelated couples in separate vehicles, described his car and another vehicle moving at excessive speed and apparently racing.
The road was a winding, two-lane rural highway. Conditions were good, and the section where the collision occurred had recently been repaired or repaved. Witnesses described the cars following closely, loud engines and a near collision with another vehicle.
Pellow argued that the trial judge had failed to consider evidence inconsistent with guilt. He suggested that the two cars were simply travelling together, questioned the reliability of witnesses’ speed estimates and proposed that an unexpected animal or momentary inattention could explain movement onto the shoulder and into oncoming traffic.
The appeal court found no overlooked material evidence supporting those alternatives. Green emphasized that several witnesses, rather than just one, had described excessive speed. Although ordinary witnesses may give estimates of speed, Pellow’s challenge concerned their reliability, not whether that type of evidence was admissible. The trial judge was entitled to consider their observations.
The court also rejected the proposition that speeding and following too closely could not support the conviction in these circumstances. Supreme Court authority recognizes that even momentary excessive speeding can establish the required fault where the full circumstances demonstrate a marked departure from reasonable driving.
The alternative explanations invited speculation. The court found the dangerous-driving verdict amply supported by the evidence.
Impairment was assessed through the whole record
A blood sample taken more than two hours after the collision showed 48 milligrams of alcohol per 100 millilitres of blood. Expert evidence put Pellow’s concentration at the time of the collision between 80 and 100 milligrams. Applying the Criminal Code’s statutory presumption, however, the trial judge determined a concentration of 58 milligrams and acquitted him of the separate count involving a concentration of at least 80 milligrams and causing death.
That did not end the inquiry into whether alcohol had impaired his ability to drive. The toxicology expert explained that impairment can reduce reaction time, divided attention, judgment and vehicle control without necessarily producing obvious outward signs.
Pellow argued that relying on the expert’s evidence about impairment in the 50-to-100-milligram range effectively created a new numerical threshold for conviction. Without additional signs of impairment, he said, the expert opinion was insufficient.
Green rejected the premise. The trial judge had not relied on the expert alone. She combined the toxicology evidence with accepted observations of excessive speed, erratic driving and loss of control immediately before the collision. The ruling therefore did not establish that everyone above 50 milligrams is guilty of impaired driving.
The court found that the combined evidence supported the conclusion that Pellow’s ability to drive was impaired by alcohol and that his driving caused his passenger’s death.
No unreasonable verdict was established
The appeal court considered whether the verdicts were ones a properly instructed jury could reasonably reach, a standard that also applies to judge-alone trials. It also considered whether essential findings had been reached illogically or irrationally, even if evidence supported the result.
Neither route justified intervention. An appeal is not an opportunity to replace supported factual and credibility findings simply because another judge might have viewed the evidence differently. Both grounds failed, and the conviction appeal was dismissed.
Source: Pellow v. R., 2026 NBCA 128.



