
A British Columbia lender can pursue a claim to correct a share purchase agreement that said there were no underground storage tanks on land used as a gas station. The Supreme Court refused to strike the rectification claim on limitation and pleading grounds, leaving the underlying contract dispute for trial.
In Brar v 628564 B.C. Ltd., 2026 BCSC 2188, Justice Ormiston also allowed Chint Kaur Brar to amend her claim with more facts about an earlier purchase agreement and environmental investigations. The October 16 ruling did not remove the disputed clause or determine that rectification was justified.
A warranty at the heart of foreclosure proceedings
Brar’s lawsuit concerns a mortgage registered in March 2023 requiring the borrower and guarantors to repay more than $5.6 million, plus interest and costs. She alleges default and seeks foreclosure relief.
The mortgage followed a February 2023 share purchase agreement. One provision said the company’s lands contained neither underground storage tanks nor hazardous substances. Brar alleges that the tank statement was an obvious error because everyone knew part of the land operated as a gas station with underground tanks. She wants the provision deleted to make the written document match the parties’ agreement.
The defendants say they relied on the provision and were prejudiced by the tanks and environmental hazards. They allege that costly environmental measures undermined the plan to refinance a short-term vendor loan. Those competing positions remain unresolved.
Brar began foreclosure proceedings by petition in December 2023. In October 2025, the court converted the petition into an action. Her March 13, 2026 amended claim expressly sought rectification for the first time.
Why a two-day limitation argument did not end the claim
The defendants argued that Brar knew of their conflicting interpretation by March 11, 2024, when they responded to the petition. On their calculation, the rectification pleading arrived two days after a two-year limitation period expired. They also relied on appellate authority treating rectification as an independent cause of action.
Brar answered that the factual basis had already emerged during the litigation. Affidavit evidence exchanged before the conversion order asserted that the buyers knew about the tanks and that the provision did not reflect the shared understanding. She characterized rectification as an extension of the existing dispute.
Ormiston declined to decide definitively whether rectification had to be formally pleaded. Striking a claim required caution where discoverability and prejudice depended on the full record. The two-year-and-two-day interval alone did not establish that the claim had to fail.
Evidence would have to be weighed about the defendants’ earlier knowledge of the claim’s factual basis and Brar’s intended remedy. Her argument that a court action became an appropriate means of seeking relief only after the conversion issue was resolved also required further factual consideration. The judge found the earlier and later factual allegations essentially identical and saw no litigation by ambush. The limitation issue was not finally resolved.
Enough facts to plead an earlier agreement
The defendants separately argued that Brar had not identified a sufficiently precise earlier agreement that the written contract supposedly misstated. Rectification requires a definite and ascertainable antecedent agreement.
Brar’s proposed amendment described a March 2021 purchase contract with an initial buyer she alleged was related to the guarantors. That contract allowed a feasibility study, including environmental clearance. She relied on two environmental reports and correspondence to support her allegation that the buyer knew about the gas station and tanks.
Ormiston found those allegations capable of identifying an antecedent agreement. Brar would still have to prove its precise nature, and the relationships between the parties to the two agreements required examination at trial. But the pleaded facts were sufficient to survive the application to strike and support the requested amendment.
The judge dismissed the defendants’ application, granted leave to amend and ordered costs in the cause, leaving costs tied to the eventual outcome of the proceeding.



