The British Columbia Court of Appeal has ordered punitive special costs for registering a replacement certificate of pending litigation to defeat a pending application to remove an earlier certificate. But it refused to extend that sanction to the appeal, finding that defending the lower court’s ruling did not itself justify punishment.

In 1316215 BC Ltd. v Davis, 2026 BCCA 449, Justice Riley awarded the successful company special costs of the Supreme Court chambers application and ordinary costs of the appeal. Justices MacNaughton and Brundrett agreed. The November 17 supplementary decision fixed the type of costs recoverable, not a dollar amount.

A replacement certificate disrupted a pending application

The dispute concerned a certificate of pending litigation, or CPL, registered against a Squamish property. A CPL preserves a claimed interest in land while litigation continues, restricting dealings with the title before the claim has been proven.

The company had applied to cancel an earlier CPL under section 252 of the Land Title Act because no step had been taken in the underlying action for more than a year. Before that application was decided, Jessica Ashley Davis brought a second action, registered a second CPL, discontinued the first action and removed the first certificate.

In its August merits ruling, 2026 BCCA 338, the appeal court accepted the finding that the second lawsuit served a legitimate protective purpose: preserving claims against additional defendants in the face of possible limitation periods. But that did not justify the subsequent use of a new CPL to frustrate the company’s existing right to have its cancellation application heard.

The court sent the matter back to the Supreme Court to assess the second certificate as though it were the first, applying the section 252 framework. It did not itself order the certificate cancelled. The November costs decision does not establish what happened on that reconsideration.

Why special costs applied below

The company sought special costs both for its chambers application and for the appeal. It pointed to the abuse of the CPL process, alleged strategic disregard of filing deadlines and what it characterized as unfounded fraud and collusion allegations.

Davis accepted that the company should receive ordinary costs at both levels, but disputed the punitive award. She argued that her second action remained a bona fide protective proceeding, that the fraud allegations had not been adjudicated and that the conduct surrounding the CPL did not meet the threshold for special costs.

Riley described special costs as exceptional and punitive, reserved for reprehensible litigation conduct, including misconduct deserving judicial rebuke. Registering the second CPL and withdrawing the first while the cancellation application was pending met that threshold. Special costs of the chambers application were necessary to punish the abuse.

Defending the appeal did not attract the same sanction

For appeal costs, the court focused on conduct in the appeal itself. Earlier misconduct could inform that assessment, but ordinarily could not alone support a punitive award at the appellate level.

Davis’s factum arrived only two weeks before the hearing, placing the court and opposing counsel in a difficult position. Still, Riley would not infer an improper purpose or characterize the delay as conduct warranting special costs. Nor did the missed deadlines below justify an additional finding of reprehensible conduct, given the proceedings’ many moving parts.

The court also rejected the company’s reliance on the fraud and collusion allegations. No court had determined their merits, so the pleadings could not be treated as advancing baseless allegations deserving punishment on that ground.

The decisive misconduct remained the use of the second CPL to circumvent the pending cancellation application. Davis’s attempt to uphold the chambers ruling did not extend that misconduct into the appeal. The company therefore received ordinary appeal costs, while retaining its special-costs award for the application below.

Source: 1316215 BC Ltd. v Davis, 2026 BCCA 449.