
Alberta business owners who sought compensation for pandemic closures have lost certification of their class action against the province. In Ingram v Alberta, the Alberta Court of Appeal found a gap in their claim. The owners attributed their losses to restrictions on their businesses, but the legal defect they relied on concerned who decided to impose those restrictions. Their pleadings offered no basis to conclude that putting the decision in the right hands would have spared them any of the losses they claimed.
Under Alberta’s Public Health Act, the chief medical officer of health or an authorized delegate had to make the final decision on the orders. A 2023 ruling found that the officer made recommendations to cabinet, which decided what to do. The officer then issued orders implementing cabinet’s decisions. The judge declared the orders invalid and found the restrictions themselves were justified under the Charter. No one appealed that ruling.
In 2024, a judge certified a class of individuals who owned Alberta businesses subject to closures or operating restrictions. The judge named Christopher Scott of the Whistle Stop Café as representative plaintiff. He allowed claims in negligence and misfeasance in public office to proceed, along with a request for a declaration that Alberta had deprived owners of the enjoyment of their property without due process.
On Alberta’s appeal, the three judges returned to the chief medical officer’s evidence from the earlier case. She had stood by her recommendations and had signed no order she considered more restrictive than necessary. The owners had suggested that cabinet might have selected the strictest option from a range she offered. The panel found no reasonable basis for concluding that she would have imposed lighter restrictions, or none at all, had she made the final call herself.
The same gap defeated the claim of misfeasance in public office. The owners alleged that cabinet knew it lacked authority and had sought to shield itself from criticism by having the chief medical officer issue the orders. The panel found it unnecessary to decide whether the owners could establish bad faith. Even if they could, the claim still had to connect the alleged misconduct to their losses.
That left the requested declaration under the Alberta Bill of Rights. The owners already had a ruling that the orders were invalid. With neither damages claim able to proceed, the panel saw little practical use in another declaration and set aside the certification order.



