The British Columbia Supreme Court has ordered a commercial lease dispute transferred out of small claims court after finding that contractual interest and legal-fee indemnity had wrongly been excluded when assessing the claim’s value.

In Davos Capital Canada ULC v Aura Cannabis Inc., 2026 BCSC 2167, Justice B. Young quashed a Provincial Court decision refusing the transfer. The October 2 judgment held that the claimed contractual obligations took the case beyond the $35,000 monetary limit at issue. It ordered the transfer directly rather than sending the question back for reconsideration.

The ruling determined where the action should proceed. It did not issue a new damages judgment for the full balance Davos claimed.

A lease claim grew beyond the amount on its front page

Davos, a real estate rental and leasing company, signed a five-year commercial lease in February 2019 with Aura Cannabis Inc. Daniel Petrov, then Aura’s chief executive, signed as an indemnifier. Aura later amalgamated into Kiaro Brands Inc.

The lease required monthly rent of $3,166.67, a share of operating expenses and municipal taxes, and reimbursement of costs and legal fees on a solicitor-client basis. It also provided for contractual interest at prime plus three per cent annually.

The reasons record that Kiaro last paid rent in August 2023. Davos began its Provincial Court claim in February 2024 and later sought to transfer the case. By November 1, 2025, it put the combined principal, contractual interest and full-indemnity legal fees at $52,219.21. That was the stated claim balance, not an amount newly awarded on judicial review.

Default judgment had already been obtained against the corporate respondents. They did not participate in the review. Petrov filed a response and agreed to the hearing date but did not attend; the application proceeded after he was paged.

The Provincial Court refused the transfer in February 2026. It focused on the $28,683.20 amount stated in the notice of claim and treated the statutory restrictions on legal fees, interest and expenses as preventing those additions from taking the case beyond its monetary jurisdiction.

Contractual obligations were part of the debt

Young first confirmed that judicial review was available. The transfer refusal was an interlocutory order, rather than an order allowing or disallowing a claim after trial, so the Small Claims Act did not provide a right of appeal. The court assessed the decision for reasonableness.

The transfer rule required a claimant to establish a preliminary case that the monetary outcome might exceed the court’s jurisdiction. Once that threshold was met, transfer was mandatory unless the claimant chose to abandon the excess.

The problem was that the Provincial Court had considered the claim only in part. Attached pages sought not just the principal sum, but damages for breach of contract, interest at the contractual rate and full-indemnity legal fees.

Young distinguished ordinary court-ordered costs and interest from sums recoverable under an express contractual obligation. The restriction on awarding one litigant another’s lawyer’s fees did not prevent a claim for a debt arising from a contractual promise to reimburse those fees. Contractual interest likewise formed part of the claim’s value.

The lease expressly contained both obligations. With those amounts included, the claim exceeded $35,000. Petrov had argued that Davos had abandoned any excess, but Young concluded that it had not. The requirements for a mandatory transfer were therefore satisfied.

A direct transfer avoided another hearing

Although judicial review ordinarily results in reconsideration by the original decision-maker, Young found the outcome inevitable. Returning the issue to the Provincial Court would serve no useful purpose and would unnecessarily delay the proceeding.

The court accordingly set aside the transfer refusal and ordered the Nanaimo action moved to the Supreme Court. It declined to make a further costs order for the petition hearing because Davos already had a contractual right to solicitor-client costs.

Source: Davos Capital Canada ULC v Aura Cannabis Inc., 2026 BCSC 2167.