
Who provided nine years of care was a crucial question in S.J. v. Industrial Alliance Auto & Home Insurance. The Licence Appeal Tribunal treated $362,880 in invoices from S.J.’s family as bills from professional support workers. When a vice-chair corrected that mistake, she left unanswered whether those expenses could still count if the insurer had unreasonably withheld or delayed a benefit payment. In reasons released November 10, Ontario’s Divisional Court explained why it sent all the claims back for a fresh hearing.
S.J. was injured in a 2014 car accident. By 2021, Industrial Alliance accepted that she was catastrophically impaired. The dispute concerned the benefits she could receive, including attendant care and non-earner benefits, and whether the insurer owed a special award for unreasonable delay or withholding of payments.
At the first hearing, the adjudicator found no proof that family members had lost income by providing care or that their services otherwise met the requirements for an incurred expense. Yet he accepted the same family invoices as professional care. He awarded $1,081.40 per month for attendant care, against a claim for $6,000 a month.
S.J. had argued that section 3(8) of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule gave the tribunal another way to assess the family care. It could treat an expense as incurred if the insurer had unreasonably withheld or delayed payment of a benefit relating to that expense. Neither the original adjudicator nor the vice-chair addressed that argument. The court left it for the new adjudicator to decide.
The panel also found that the original adjudicator overlooked an occupational therapist’s testimony that she had reviewed records he believed she had missed. He could reject her recommendations, the judges explained, but her reports were evidence that S.J. needed care at or near the maximum rate. His statement that there was no such evidence could not be reconciled with the record.
On reconsideration, the vice-chair sent only the non-earner benefit and the related special award back for a written rehearing. That rehearing produced a non-earner benefit award and denied the special award. The court concluded that the problems with the original hearing also required a fresh assessment of attendant care.
In its May ruling, the panel allowed S.J.’s appeal, set aside all three tribunal decisions and directed that a different adjudicator hear all issues. It asked the tribunal to expedite the hearing, subject to counsel’s and witnesses’ schedules. It dismissed the companion judicial review because the appeal had resolved the issues before the court. Industrial Alliance was ordered to pay S.J. $5,000 in agreed costs for both proceedings.



