An Ontario company’s lawsuit alleging fraudulent transfers of three properties can continue after a judge rejected a defendant’s attempt to have it dismissed for delay. Eesan Subramaniam brought the motion about three and a quarter years after the action began. Associate Justice Rappos found that he had failed to establish inordinate delay under the civil procedure rules, applying a five-year benchmark from the Court of Appeal.

The November 12 ruling in 2249419 Ontario v. Subramaniam also rejected an attempt to end the lawsuit over alleged failures to produce documents and follow a discovery plan. The court had made no finding that the plaintiff breached those obligations. The merits of the property-transfer allegations remain to be decided.

The company started its action in June 2022. The defendants demanded particulars, and Subramaniam moved to strike the claim or require more detail. A June 2023 consent order allowed the company to amend its claim, dismissed the rest of that motion and barred further motions for particulars. The amended claim followed in July 2023. Subramaniam served his delay motion in September 2025. By the June 2026 hearing, the action was just over four years old.

How the court measured the delay

Rule 24.01 allows a defendant to seek dismissal when a plaintiff has not set the action down for trial within six months after pleadings close. The defendant must establish inordinate delay, an inexcusable delay and a substantial risk that the delay prevents a fair trial. All three requirements must be met.

Subramaniam argued that no fixed period determines whether delay is inordinate and that each case turns on its facts. Rappos relied on the Court of Appeal’s decision in Barbiero v. Pollack, which used the rules’ five-year period for setting an action down as the benchmark for ordinary progress. Under that reasoning, an action begins to enter the realm of inordinate delay after five years.

The earlier cases Subramaniam cited did not persuade the judge to apply a shorter period. One involved a claim more than five years old. Another concerned a construction lien, governed by a separate statute requiring readiness for trial within two years and giving the court a different power to dismiss. A third applied an earlier version of the rules with a two-year deadline measured from the first defence.

Subramaniam also stressed that the company had chosen simplified procedure, a stream intended to resolve claims more quickly. Rappos accepted that purpose but found that the simplified procedure rule did not change the test for dismissal for delay. The comparable case offered by Subramaniam involved nine years between commencement and dismissal.

Fraud allegations and outstanding documents

Subramaniam argued that allegations of fraudulent conveyance required faster action because leaving such allegations unresolved could harm a defendant’s reputation. Rappos accepted that fraud proceedings should move more quickly than ordinary disputes. But the authorities Subramaniam relied on involved delays exceeding eight years. The judge found that using them to require this plaintiff to advance its case far faster than the five-year benchmark would overreach.

With inordinate delay unproven, Rappos did not need to decide whether the delay was excusable or whether it prejudiced a fair trial. He also declined to invoke inherent jurisdiction to dismiss the action, explaining that his authority as an associate judge had to come from statute.

The discovery arguments stood separately. Subramaniam added them to his motion less than three weeks before the hearing, alleging missing documents about rent and other matters and a breach of a court-ordered discovery plan. The company had served an affidavit of documents in November 2023 and a supplementary affidavit in July 2025. Subramaniam had sought no order compelling a further affidavit or additional disclosure. His submissions also failed to explain the applicable test for striking a pleading over document production and how the facts met it.

Rappos refused to dismiss the action without a finding that the company had breached its discovery obligations. He urged the parties to agree on costs, leaving written submissions available if they could not.

Read the Ontario Superior Court’s reasons on CanLII.