A former Saskatchewan government executive could not continue deducting home-office costs as employment expenses after her job ended, even though she kept an apartment to work with counsel on her dismissal lawsuit, the Tax Court of Canada has ruled.

In Schell v. The King, 2026 TCC 200, decided November 12, Justice Perry Derksen dismissed appeals concerning the 2021 and 2022 taxation years without costs. The decision turned on the statutory connection required between the expenses and employment, as well as the evidence supporting particular claims.

Some deductions had already been restored

Tiffany Schell took a full-time executive-director position with Saskatchewan’s Ministry of Finance in November 2020 and rented an apartment in Regina while retaining a residence in Edmonton. Her employment ended effective May 31, 2021. She did not start another job during the remainder of 2021 or in 2022.

She sued her former employer and settled in April 2022. Her tax returns claimed employment deductions for home-office costs, supplies and legal fees. Although the Minister initially disallowed the claimed expenses on reassessment, later reassessments allowed all the legal fees sought and some home-office and supply costs for January through May 2021.

The dispute before the court therefore did not concern whether those legal fees should be allowed. It concerned the remaining deductions and related employee GST rebate claims.

Keeping the apartment for litigation was not enough

The court explained that the Income Tax Act permits only specified deductions from employment income. The office-rent and supplies provisions at issue require, among other things, an obligation under the employment contract. Additional conditions apply to a workspace in a home and to employer certification.

Schell sought to deduct expenses based on using at least half the Regina apartment for work. The Minister had allowed 37 per cent for the months when she remained employed. The judge accepted that a bedroom served as an office and that other areas were sometimes used for work, but did not accept the asserted extent of team meetings and use by other employees. He found no basis for a deduction above the percentage already allowed.

For the period after termination, maintaining the apartment to assist with litigation did not make its costs expenses required by an employment contract. There was no new employment to support the claims. The same problem applied in 2022, when the required employer certificate was also missing.

The settlement payment was treated as a retiring allowance rather than continuing employment income. That treatment did not create an entitlement to the home-office deductions claimed.

Receipts alone did not establish the remaining claims

The court also rejected additional supplies claims. Some purchases had occurred in the wrong taxation year, some were durable furnishings rather than supplies consumed in performing employment duties, and others were made after employment ended. The judge emphasized the need for evidence explaining the purchases, not simply a bundle of receipts previously provided to the tax authority.

Moving expenses claimed for 2022 also failed. Schell had not moved to Edmonton to take up new employment, so the relocation did not meet the relevant statutory requirement considered by the court.

The employee GST rebate claims were unsupported by evidence of a prescribed application or the relevant GST paid on allowed home-office expenses. The dismissal left the reassessments in place, including the deductions the Minister had already allowed.