The Tax Court of Canada has refused the Crown’s request for full reimbursement of legal costs in a corporate tax dispute, while awarding a $5,000 lump sum because the ordinary tariff would inadequately reflect the work involved.

In 941624 Alberta Ltd. v. The King, 2026 TCC 202, issued November 16, Chief Justice Gabrielle St-Hilaire rejected arguments that the company’s litigation conduct, refusal of a global settlement offer and cross-examination of a tax official justified the requested costs treatment.

Three tax years had been removed from the appeal

The company challenged reassessments for 2019 through 2022 involving unreported income and denied expenses. The Crown successfully moved to quash the appeals for 2020, 2021 and 2022 because the company had not met the statutory objection requirements applicable to large corporations.

The new reasons record that an appeal from that ruling to the Federal Court of Appeal was subsequently discontinued. The company’s 2019 appeal and two related shareholder appeals remained unresolved.

The Crown sought $13,482.98 in solicitor-and-client costs, representing full indemnification for the motion, or alternatively elevated costs. The company argued for no award or, failing that, costs under the tariff. The Crown’s tariff comparison was $2,884.80 including disbursements.

Sharp correspondence did not meet the sanctions threshold

The Crown relied on accusations that it had improperly obtained consent to an extension for filing its replies while withholding plans to bring the motion to quash. The company questioned the timing of the extension request and subsequent motion.

The Chief Justice found that the frustration expressed in the correspondence did not amount to reprehensible, scandalous or outrageous conduct warranting solicitor-and-client costs. She did not decide whether the consent extension should be set aside, an issue outside the costs ruling.

A global offer could not be measured against a partial result

The Crown had made a settlement offer covering the company and both shareholders, expressly conditional on settling all the appeals together. The special substantial-indemnity provisions were not engaged because the offer expired too early, but a written offer could still be considered in the court’s general costs discretion.

The difficulty was comparison. The Crown had won the motion concerning three tax years, not the remaining company appeal or the shareholder cases. The court could not separate the interdependent settlement terms or assume the outcome of the unresolved proceedings. The offer therefore did not favour enhanced costs.

The court also refused to treat cross-examination of a CRA officer as an unnecessary step merely because the Crown considered it unproductive. The officer’s affidavit was a significant part of the Crown’s case. The judge declined to judge the necessity of testing that evidence through hindsight.

Tariff was a reference point, not a ceiling

Rejecting those grounds did not require the court to use the tariff. The costs rules give it discretion to fix a lump sum with or without reference to tariff amounts.

The Chief Justice found the tariff inadequate and awarded $5,000 to reflect the Crown’s success and the work involved. She expressly distinguished that amount from both the full-indemnity request and the alternative enhanced award sought. The result was a compensatory costs determination, not a finding that the company deserved punishment for litigation misconduct.