
The Royal Ontario Museum was not eligible for the Canada Emergency Wage Subsidy for the periods disputed in its tax appeal because it was a public institution, the Tax Court has ruled.
In Royal Ontario Museum v. The King, 2026 TCC 201, decided November 17, Justice Randall Bocock dismissed the museum’s appeal from determinations denying CEWS for four periods in late 2020 and summer 2021. The dispute turned on Ontario’s ownership and control of the capital of a corporation without share capital, rather than any failure to satisfy the program’s other requirements.
Charitable status did not settle eligibility
The ROM is a registered charity incorporated without share capital under provincial legislation. It generates revenue from admissions, memberships, donations and other activities, and also receives foundation and provincial grants. It argued that its own ownership of its money and assets, and the absence of a Crown-agency relationship, meant that it was not a public institution excluded from CEWS.
The statutory definition of an eligible entity allowed registered charities to qualify, but excluded public institutions. That exclusion referred to provisions dealing with corporations whose capital was owned by the federal or a provincial Crown.
Applying that language to a corporation with shares was relatively straightforward. Applying it to a non-share corporation was not: such entities generally hold legal title to their own assets. The judge concluded that a title-only interpretation would largely prevent the exclusion from operating for publicly controlled non-share corporations.
Control mattered more than counting factors
The Crown proposed the CRA’s established multi-factor approach to identifying ownership of non-share capital. Its considerations included membership and structure, financial and operational control, appointment of directors, capital contributions and distribution of assets on winding up.
The court did not treat that administrative approach as binding law. It gave the approach weight as an interpretive aid where the statutory language was uncertain and the CEWS context offered little directly applicable authority.
Nor did the court find that every factor favoured the Crown. Only three clearly supported Ontario’s position: financial control, the ability to appoint and change directors, and control over distribution of assets. Their importance outweighed the numerical tally of neutral or inapplicable factors.
During the relevant period, Ontario’s cabinet appointed 15 trustees and selected the board chair. The museum required provincial approval for its business plan and faced statutory restrictions on real-property dealings and borrowing. The court also considered provincial oversight, the ability to recoup surplus funds and legislative control over the museum’s ultimate disposition.
Crown agency was not the necessary test
The judge accepted, narrowly, that Ontario’s control did not establish the Crown-agency relationship advanced in the ROM’s proposed test. But he rejected the proposition that the absence of that relationship answered the separate CEWS question.
In the court’s view, the museum’s operational independence did not erase Ontario’s effective control of its capital and undertaking. Reading the provisions in context supported treating the ROM as a public institution, consistently with Parliament’s exclusion of public-sector entities from the wage subsidy.
The result concerns the museum’s statutory structure and the disputed CEWS periods. It does not remove the ROM’s charitable status or establish that every government-funded charity is ineligible. Tariff costs were provisionally awarded to the Crown, subject to further written submissions within the timetable set by the court.



