The Federal Court of Appeal has rejected Toronto-Dominion Bank’s claim that Aeroplan Miles issued to its credit-card customers were gift certificates, defeating its argument that GST and HST paid in connection with those Miles should be rebated.

In Toronto-Dominion Bank v. Canada, 2026 FCA 193, decided November 13, 2026, Justice Nathalie Goyette, writing for a unanimous three-judge panel, agreed with the Tax Court’s result but not all of its reasoning. The appeal was dismissed with costs, with the court retaining jurisdiction over costs for 60 days to allow written submissions.

Why the bank sought a rebate

TD’s agreement with Aimia Canada Inc., referred to in the reasons as Aeroplan, allowed the bank to have Miles issued to participating cardholders when they made purchases. TD paid an amount for each Mile, together with GST or HST.

The bank later argued that it had paid that tax in error. Section 181.2 of the Excise Tax Act treats the issuance or sale of a gift certificate for payment as not being a supply. When the certificate is later exchanged for property or services, it is treated as money. If Miles qualified, TD argued, tax should not have been payable when it paid Aeroplan to issue them.

The Tax Court rejected that position in 2024 TCC 50. The appeal turned on the meaning of “gift certificate,” a term the legislation does not define.

Earned rewards were different from gifts

The appeal court examined the provision’s wording, statutory setting and purpose. It concluded that the ordinary meaning of a gift certificate did not fit the Miles at issue.

Cardholders had to enrol in Aeroplan, use a participating credit card and keep their account in good standing to earn Miles. Their rewards depended on participation and spending, rather than an entitlement received without those obligations. When TD paid Aeroplan, it was fulfilling its contractual commitment to the cardholder, not making a gift.

The terms governing the Miles also mattered. The reasons identified cancellation powers and provisions allowing changes to the program that could affect accumulated Miles. Those contingent rights differed from the entitlement to goods or services associated with a gift certificate.

The court found support elsewhere in the Excise Tax Act. Its definition of a virtual payment instrument separately excludes certain rights redeemable for goods or services and property used in rewards programs. That distinction suggested Parliament regarded gift-certificate-like property and reward points as different concepts.

Provincial consumer-protection legislation reinforced the distinction. In particular, Ontario and Quebec regulate reward points separately from gift certificates or their modern equivalents. The court also considered the historical difference between gifts and loyalty rewards earned through repeated purchases, while acknowledging that Parliament had not directly explained the purpose of section 181.2.

The tax consequences did not change the answer

TD argued that denying gift-certificate treatment could produce unreasonable tax results. Its examples included Miles redeemed for gift cards, Miles used for international flights and Miles never redeemed.

The court rejected those examples as a reason to change the interpretation. It explained that the bank’s general inability to recover GST through input tax credits reflected Parliament’s policy choice for financial institutions, whose financial services are generally exempt. That did not make the result absurd.

Two further examples depended on the tax treatment of Miles when redeemed. The record contained no evidence establishing that treatment, so the court declined to decide those arguments.

A narrow ruling, not a universal definition

The appeal court deliberately stopped short of defining every instrument that could qualify as a gift certificate. It also disagreed with the Tax Court’s view that a certificate must state a monetary value. A voucher for a specified free service, such as a one-hour spa treatment, could fall within the ordinary meaning even without a dollar amount.

Justice Goyette suggested legislation could provide greater certainty and better account for modern gift certificates and coupons. But the court’s ruling was narrower: the Aeroplan Miles before it were not gift certificates under section 181.2. That conclusion disposed of the appeal without deciding the Crown’s alternative arguments.

The decision concerns the bank’s tax treatment of the arrangements in evidence. It does not determine every loyalty program’s tax position or establish that consumers’ rewards are taxable income.