A Texas pipe supplier that failed to answer an Alberta lawsuit will remain in default after the Alberta Court of Appeal rejected its bid to file a defence. In Secure Energy Services Inc v Lone Star Pipe & Supply LLC, the court explained why a judge has more room to reopen a case at this stage than after a default judgment, and why that flexibility did not help Lone Star.

Secure Energy sued several companies over allegedly defective tubing. It added Lone Star as a defendant in November 2022, alleging that the company had negligently designed, manufactured or supplied the tubing. Under a court order authorizing service outside Alberta, Secure Energy sent the amended claim by registered mail to Lone Star’s registered agent at the address on file in Texas. A receptionist signed for the package. Lone Star filed no defence and was noted in default on January 30, 2023.

Lone Star said the claim had come to its attention only in May, when it applied to set aside the default. An applications judge allowed it to defend, but a chambers judge restored the default. One explanation Lone Star offered was that it had sold its registered address in an earlier asset sale. Its counsel later acknowledged that the sale concerned a different address. The appeal panel also found that the chambers judge had been entitled to rely on a gap in the company’s evidence. Its manager denied personal knowledge of the claim but gave no explanation for how the company had missed it despite the documented deliveries.

A noting in default records a defendant’s failure to respond. The defendant remains a party but is deemed to admit the allegations and loses the ability to contest liability. If the amount of damages still has to be established, the defendant can contest that amount. A default judgment takes the proceeding a step further, and its finality carries weight when a court is asked to reopen it.

The panel said judges at either stage can ask whether there is an arguable defence, whether the defendant has an excuse for the default and how quickly it acted after learning of it. Those questions guide the court’s discretion under Alberta’s Rules of Court. For instance, delay that caused no prejudice may carry less weight before judgment, while an inability to identify any arguable defence may count heavily at either stage.

Lone Star argued that the size of the claim and the strength of its proposed defence weighed in its favour. Secure Energy pointed to its right to rely on litigation deadlines. The panel found that the chambers judge had weighed the competing interests and made a decision open to her. The November 9 judgment dismissed Lone Star’s appeal. It set no amount of damages.

Source: Read the Alberta Court of Appeal’s decision on CanLII.