Ibrahim Abouzeid must pay a combined $166,918 in legal costs to eXp Realty of Canada and its parent company after both obtained orders staying his Ontario lawsuit. Justice Cavanagh reduced the companies’ requests, finding that the legal work they billed exceeded what Abouzeid could reasonably have expected to pay if he lost. The court also declined their requests for a higher level of costs based on settlement offers.

The November 9 ruling in Abouzeid v. eXp Realty of Canada Inc et al. fixes the cost of two motions heard on the same day. eXp Canada obtained a stay under the Arbitration Act. eXp World Holdings obtained its stay on forum non conveniens grounds, concerning the appropriate forum for the dispute. The costs ruling does not determine whether the contract was wrongfully terminated.

Abouzeid founded the Affinity Real Estate Group in 2018 and signed an independent contractor agreement with eXp Canada in March 2022. After the company terminated that agreement in September 2025, he sued in January 2026 seeking relief that included enforcement of the contract. In the earlier arbitration ruling, Cavanagh rejected Abouzeid’s argument that requiring JAMS to administer the arbitration prevented an independent decision-maker. The agreement permitted arbitrators from outside JAMS’ roster, and Abouzeid had supplied no affidavit establishing vulnerability in the contracting process.

In the separate ruling on eXp World, the court found no basis to treat the parent and subsidiary as a single entity. Abouzeid’s relationship with the parent was as a shareholder, and the agreements governing his shareholdings assigned disputes to Delaware’s courts. He had shown no reason to override that choice.

What the arbitration motion should cost

eXp Canada initially sought $130,028.05, combining partial indemnity costs up to its March 10 settlement offer with substantial indemnity costs afterward. Its offer would have sent the claims to arbitration, left accrued costs to be resolved with the case, and expressly allowed the arbitrator to consider Abouzeid’s contemplated injunction.

Cavanagh found the offer did not trigger substantial indemnity costs under the rules and saw no other basis for that higher scale. Even on the lower scale, however, eXp Canada’s costs outline came to $123,104.06, including $107,446.65 in fees before tax. Those fees were calculated at 60 per cent of the lawyers’ actual rates.

Abouzeid proposed $41,864.93, the amount in his own partial indemnity outline. He challenged the use of three lawyers and the time spent on what he considered a straightforward motion. The supporting evidence included a four-page affidavit from eXp Canada’s managing director. The cross-examination of a law clerk lasted 30 minutes.

Cavanagh accepted that the motion mattered to the parties but found that it was not unduly complex and that its legal principles were settled. He examined 78.8 lawyer hours for preparing the motion record and 47.6 hours connected with the law clerk’s cross-examination, along with the other work. Those two categories particularly concerned him. Applying the principle that costs depend on what is fair and reasonable for the unsuccessful party to pay, he fixed fees at $75,000.

A separate reduction for the parent company

eXp World sought $115,983.75 in fees, plus tax and disbursements, using the same request for an increase after its March 10 offer. Cavanagh again refused an elevated scale. The parent’s partial indemnity fees were $97,636.35.

The company accepted that the law was not complex but said Abouzeid had made the motion harder by omitting contracts from his pleading, failing to address its arguments and treating the two companies’ motions without proper distinction. Abouzeid disputed the size of the bill and proposed $42,671.75, matching his own costs outline.

Cavanagh again found that the time claimed by three lawyers, particularly on the motion record and preparation for cross-examinations, exceeded what Abouzeid could reasonably expect to pay. He fixed fees at $70,000.

With HST and disbursements added, eXp Canada’s award is $86,284 and eXp World’s is $80,634. The order requires each amount to be paid within 30 days.

Read the Ontario Superior Court’s costs endorsement on CanLII.