A Manitoba judge has refused to make a company's chief executive explain the relevance of a sample of documents in a wrongful dismissal lawsuit, finding that the proposed questioning lacked an evidentiary foundation and was unfair and disproportionate in the setting of a motion to dismiss for delay.

In McLeod v. Tribal Councils Investment Group of Manitoba Ltd., 2026 MBKB 155, Associate Judge J. L. Goldenberg dismissed Allan Christopher McLeod's motion to compel answers on cross-examination. The ruling did not decide his former employer's pending delay motion or the merits of his wrongful dismissal claim.

The decision draws a distinction between questioning a witness on an affidavit filed for a motion and examining a corporate representative for discovery. It also expressly leaves room for appropriate questions about how documents were collected, categorized or disclosed.

A proposed day of document questions

Tribal Councils Investment Group sought to dismiss the action for delay and significant prejudice. During cross-examination connected with that motion, McLeod's lawyer asked the CEO how a document listed in the company's revised affidavit of documents was relevant to his termination. Defence counsel objected and directed her not to answer.

The revised list contained close to 22,000 documents. McLeod eventually identified about 112 documents he wished to ask about, a process his lawyer acknowledged would require a full day of cross-examination.

In his affidavit responding to the delay motion, McLeod had alleged that the company's production of 110,000 documents in 2015, release of a report in 2017 and revised production exceeding 20,000 documents in 2019 appeared intended to delay the litigation. He argued that this allegation entitled him to explore whether many documents were irrelevant.

Goldenberg accepted that the proposed inquiry had an arguable connection to delay. But McLeod's affidavit did not allege that the productions contained substantial numbers of irrelevant or duplicate documents, or say that he had reviewed them and reached that conclusion.

He supplied that kind of evidence on the later motion to compel answers. The judge held that it could not retrospectively expand the scope of the earlier cross-examination. The problem was not that the questions were wholly unrelated to delay, but that their specific factual premise was absent from the evidentiary record when the examination occurred.

The CEO's knowledge and role

The judge identified a further, independent difficulty: although the CEO had sworn the document affidavits, the evidence did not establish that she personally made the individual relevance decisions. An electronic discovery provider and counsel had assisted with the disclosure process.

Asking her why particular documents were included was therefore unlikely to produce reliable or meaningful evidence about those decisions, Goldenberg found.

A corporate representative examined for discovery has a duty to inform herself and answer for the company. A person cross-examined on an affidavit answers as a witness and has no equivalent duty, the judge explained.

The revised affidavit had been sworn more than six and a half years before the examination. The CEO had no obligation to review its documents beforehand. She had also joined the company after McLeod's employment ended, leaving her without first-hand knowledge of the termination events or demonstrated familiarity with many documents he proposed to raise.

A disproportionate inquiry, not a blanket ban

The court also found a real risk that the inquiry would become a broad review of disclosure decisions rather than a focused examination on the delay motion. Cross-examination on an affidavit attracts considerable latitude, but must remain fair and cannot substitute for discovery.

McLeod and his lawyer had not reviewed the listed documents for a considerable period after production. There was no evidence that he formed his view about irrelevance or duplication until years later. Even if some documents proved irrelevant or repetitive, the judge considered their connection to delay attributable to the company weak, reinforcing the proportionality concern.

Goldenberg expressly declined to prohibit all cross-examination about document disclosure or relevance. The ruling turned on this record: insufficient foundation, an unsuitable witness for the proposed inquiry, unfair questions and disproportionate demands.

The motion to compel answers was dismissed. If the parties cannot agree on costs, counsel may return to address that issue.

Read the full decision on CanLII.