The Tax Court has rejected a second attempt to reopen a discontinued 2005 tax appeal, holding that an affidavit filed by the taxpayer’s own lawyers years earlier did not qualify as newly discovered evidence.

Associate Judge Andrew Miller also refused permission to examine two Canada Revenue Agency officers. The November 4 decision in Laquerre v. The King says that discovery could not proceed in the absence of a valid appeal, and would not cure the basic defects in the reopening request in any event.

A settlement followed by two reopening attempts

Mario Laquerre began tax appeals in 2011. His bankruptcy trustee settled them in 2014, and notices of discontinuance were filed. Under the Tax Court’s statute, discontinuance has the effect of dismissing an appeal.

Laquerre first sought to reopen the appeals in 2022, without success. He appealed that order to the Federal Court of Appeal but discontinued the appellate proceeding in March 2024.

The latest motion targeted the 2022 order and sought to revive only the 2005 appeal. Laquerre relied on a 2007 affidavit that he said he obtained from the Federal Court registry in October 2024.

The court could hear the motion, but its strict test was not met

The judge distinguished discontinuance in the Tax Court from discontinuance in the Federal Court of Appeal. The latter ends the proceeding without a merits judgment. Because the appellate court had not decided the merits, the Tax Court retained jurisdiction to consider the motion against its own order.

The court also rejected the Crown’s argument that res judicata, the rule against relitigating decided matters, automatically barred the motion. This application targeted a different order and relied on a different asserted factual basis from the earlier reopening request.

Those conclusions allowed the motion to be considered; they did not establish a right to reopen the appeal. Paragraph 172(2)(a) imposes demanding conditions where newly discovered facts are relied upon: the facts must be new, must not reasonably have been discoverable earlier and must probably have produced a different result.

Laquerre failed all three. His lawyers had filed the affidavit in a Federal Court proceeding on his behalf in 2007. The court was not persuaded that receiving another copy in 2024 amounted to discovering new facts, or that reasonable inquiries to his former lawyers could not have produced the document earlier.

The evidence also did not show that the affidavit would have changed the trustee’s 2014 settlement. There was no direct evidence from the trustee establishing that the information was unknown or would have affected the agreement. Allegations about the CRA’s conduct did not establish fraud or non-disclosure connected with that settlement.

Discovery could not supply a missing appeal

The judge decided the reopening motion before the discovery request because the right to discovery depended on a valid appeal or reference. With reopening refused, there was no appeal in which the proposed examinations could take place.

Alternatively, the discovery motion was frivolous because even the evidence Laquerre hoped to obtain would not address the first two failures: whether the affidavit’s facts were newly discovered and whether they could reasonably have been found before the 2022 order.

No costs because of the Crown’s limited participation

Both motions were dismissed without costs. Although the Crown succeeded, the judge found that its limited participation, including a late response and silence on other requests, unnecessarily prolonged the process.

The decision concerns finality, reopening and discovery. It does not reconsider the correctness of the original 2005 tax assessment on its merits.

Read the official French judgment and reasons. This is an unofficial English-language report.