
The Tax Court has allowed a buyer’s appeal from an $8,244.76 GST reassessment on the assignment of a pre-sale contract for an unfinished British Columbia condominium.
In Jiang v. The King, 2026 TCC 188, decided November 4, Justice Sylvain Ouimet held that the 2019 assignment transferred contractual rights, not real property. The Crown’s alternative grounds for maintaining the reassessment had not been adequately pleaded, and relying on them would have been unfair to the self-represented taxpayer. The appeal was allowed without costs.
Contract rights were not the unfinished strata lot
The original purchaser, a non-resident of Canada, agreed in 2015 to buy a proposed Vancouver strata lot from a developer. In February 2019, he assigned his rights and obligations under that agreement to Ling Jiang. Construction was incomplete, and the strata lot had not yet been legally created through subdivision. Jiang completed the purchase from the developer in March 2020.
Jiang initially reported and remitted $20,304.76 in GST. Following reassessments and an objection, the disputed amount was reduced to $8,244.76. The Crown maintained that the assignment was a taxable supply of real property by a non-resident, making Jiang responsible for remitting the tax.
The court first examined the nature of the property supplied. Applying British Columbia property law, it found that the original purchaser had no legal interest in the uncreated strata lot. Nor did he have an equitable interest arising from an entitlement to specific performance: construction remained to be done, and nobody argued that such a remedy was available.
What passed to Jiang was the contractual right to acquire the future unit. That was personal property under the Excise Tax Act, so the provisions relied on for self-assessment of real-property supplies did not apply. The judge distinguished cases involving different property, statutory questions or provincial law.
Alternative tax arguments required proper notice
The Crown also argued that the transfer remained taxable even if characterized as personal property. That raised a different question: whether the supply was made in Canada for GST purposes.
The Act can deem a non-resident’s supply of personal property to occur outside Canada, subject to exceptions including a supply made in the course of a business carried on in Canada. But the Crown had not adequately put that factual issue in dispute. Its pleaded assumptions referred to a business or an adventure in the nature of trade, without identifying a business carried on in Canada.
The judge declined to make the necessary findings on an issue for which Jiang had not received proper notice and to which evidence had not been directed. The court also refused to uphold the assessment using the unpleaded provision permitting direct assessment of a recipient.
A further argument invoked section 133, which deems an agreement to provide property to be a supply of that property. The judge said the assignment concerned contractual rights rather than an undertaking by the assignor to provide the unit. Independently, the provision had not been pleaded, and references around the hearing did not give sufficient notice to respond.
A transaction-specific result
The ruling did not establish a general GST exemption for condominium assignments. It concerned this 2019 transaction, the rights transferred under British Columbia law and the grounds on which the Crown sought to defend the reassessment. Because the court could not find a taxable supply on the case presented, it did not need to decide whether an exemption applied.
Although Jiang sought costs, the court held that the applicable informal-procedure rule barred an award because the amount in dispute exceeded $7,000.



