The buyers of an Ontario heating and air-conditioning business must pay the sellers $250,000 in legal costs after abandoning allegations of fraud on the first day of trial. The judge found that keeping those allegations alive through years of litigation warranted higher costs, but that some of the same facts raised legitimate contract questions worth trying.

In 1916458 Ontario Limited v. Beaulieu, 2026 ONSC 6230, Justice M.G. Ellies gave the buyers six months to pay the all-inclusive award. It comes on top of a separate $86,275.34 judgment for damages and prejudgment interest in favour of the sellers, Denis and Karen Beaulieu.

The dispute arose from the 2015 purchase of DenKar Controls Inc. for $500,000. The buyers alleged that the Beaulieus had misrepresented the state of the business, including by failing to disclose layoffs, declining revenues and reductions in management salaries. They claimed $500,000 in damages and sought additional relief, including punitive damages. The Beaulieus denied the allegations and counterclaimed for the $78,500 balance of the purchase price.

Before trial, the Beaulieus offered to dismiss both sides’ claims. Each side would bear its own costs if the buyers accepted by April 25, 2025. After that deadline, the offer remained open until one minute after the trial began, with the buyers responsible for costs on the terms the sellers had proposed. The buyers did not accept. They dropped fraudulent misrepresentation at the opening of trial and proceeded on breach of contract. After eleven trial days, the court dismissed their claim and allowed the counterclaim.

The Beaulieus sought $274,303.73 to cover their full legal costs. Ellies accepted that the amount was reasonable, but found that the buyers’ conduct did not meet the exceptional threshold for full reimbursement. Although they had maintained the fraud allegations through pleadings, document production and discovery, much of that evidence would also have been relevant to the contract claim. Whether layoffs and salary reductions should have been disclosed under the purchase agreement, for example, was a question the buyers could properly put to the court even though they lost.

The settlement offer also mattered. As claimants on the counterclaim, the Beaulieus had achieved a better result at trial than the mutual dismissal they had offered. They calculated costs based on the offer at $231,303.73. Ellies fixed costs above that figure to reflect the buyers’ litigation conduct, while allowing for the overlap between the abandoned allegations and the contract issues that went to trial. In setting the payment period, the judge took account of the size of the award and the individual buyers’ difficulties restoring the company’s profitability.

Source: Read the court’s costs ruling on CanLII.