
The Tax Court has refused an extension of time to object to a tax reassessment while strongly encouraging the Canada Revenue Agency to consider accepting the taxpayer’s earlier letter as a valid objection.
In Sidhu v. The King, 2026 TCC 189, issued November 2, Justice J. Scott Bodie dismissed Sukhjinder Sidhu’s application without costs. Her request to the minister had arrived 12 days after the statutory extension deadline. The court could not excuse that delay, even though it accepted her evidence and recognized her continuing intention to dispute the assessment.
One transaction, but only one identified objector
The dispute arose from the 2021 sale of a jointly owned Chilliwack property. Sidhu and her husband each reported half the gain as a capital gain. The CRA proposed treating the profit as business income and sent each spouse a proposal letter.
Both responded in writing in November 2024, disagreeing with that proposed treatment. After the CRA issued reassessments in January 2025, they instructed their accountant to object and supplied the necessary authorizations.
The accountant filed a timely online objection in April 2025, but entered only the husband’s identifying information. Its explanation described the couple’s circumstances collectively. When Sidhu later received collection correspondence, her accountant reassured her that an objection had been filed.
Following a further collection warning, a separate objection identifying Sidhu was filed on May 12, 2026. The CRA treated it as an extension application, but the one-year period for seeking that extension had expired on April 30.
Fairness could not enlarge the court’s power
The court explained that the statutory conditions for an extension were cumulative. A timely application to the minister within the extension period was indispensable. Because that condition was not met, the judge did not need to consider the remaining requirements.
The deadlines were imposed by Parliament, and the court could not extend them on equitable grounds. That remained true where an accountant or other agent was responsible for the missed step. Accepting the taxpayer’s explanation did not confer a power the statute withheld.
An earlier letter offered a different possibility
In a lengthy postscript, Justice Bodie distinguished his limited jurisdiction from the minister’s discretion to accept objections that do not comply with formal requirements.
He discussed earlier cases recognizing that a taxpayer’s response to a written reassessment proposal may qualify as an objection to the reassessment subsequently issued. The statutory wording requires service on or before the deadline, rather than expressly restricting service to the period after the reassessment is sent. Those cases also recognized limits on the Tax Court’s ability to declare an objection valid.
Sidhu’s November 2024 response clearly challenged the position that became the reassessment. The CRA knew of that disagreement. The spouses had acted together in the property transaction and audit, and Sidhu had instructed the accountant to object on her behalf. The judge strongly encouraged the minister to consider recognizing that response as a validly filed objection.
That encouragement was not an order granting relief. The extension application remained dismissed, and the reasons did not resolve whether the property gain was capital or business income. They also did not establish that the CRA subsequently accepted the earlier letter.



