
Chantelle Cheekinew can rely on excerpts from two national inquiry reports when asking a court to certify her proposed class action over Saskatchewan’s use of birth alerts. The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal dismissed the province’s challenge to the use of the reports at the certification hearing, leaving the question of whether they could be used at a trial for another day.
In Saskatchewan v Cheekinew, 2026 SKCA 117, Chief Justice Robert Leurer wrote for a unanimous panel that the reports met the requirements of the public documents exception to the hearsay rule. The purpose for which Cheekinew offered the excerpts mattered. The certification judge could consider them in deciding whether the claims should proceed together and would determine how much weight to give them.
Birth alerts asked health-care providers to contact child protection services because a newborn might be at risk. Cheekinew alleges that she was subject to alerts before the births of three of her children. She claims the province issued alerts without legal justification and that the practice disproportionately targeted Indigenous, racialized or disabled pregnant people. The appeal concerned what evidence the certification judge could consider, leaving those allegations unresolved.
Why the reports qualified as public documents
Cheekinew attached excerpts from the 2019 final report of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls and the 2015 summary report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada to her affidavit. She said they offered historical context for her experience and could help establish a factual basis for certification.
The province accepted that the excerpts dealt with public matters and that the commissions had produced them for public use as lasting records. Its challenge focused on who prepared them and under what authority. Leurer explained that the exception turns on whether the author was carrying out a public duty. The author need not be a government employee, and an inquiry need not conduct its hearings like a court.
The province questioned whether the truth and reconciliation commissioners were carrying out a public duty because the commission originated in the Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement. Leurer pointed out that an order in council established the commission and adopted the mandate from the agreement. The commissioners of both inquiries were public officials, and the excerpts concerned matters within their respective mandates.
The limits of the ruling
The province argued that the reports contained accounts its lawyers could not test through cross-examination. It pointed in particular to the voluntary, unsworn information gathered by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission. The court accepted that a judge can exclude a public document if using it would be unreliable or unfair.
The judges drew a distinction between two uses of an inquiry report. In an earlier contaminated-blood lawsuit, the plaintiff wanted to use an inquiry’s findings to establish liability at trial. The defendants could not cross-examine the report or test the evidence behind particular findings. In Cheekinew’s case, one proposed use was to identify evidence that might become available if the action proceeded. A report could point to a source of evidence without proving what happened to any class member.
Cheekinew still had to show some factual basis for matters such as whether the proposed class was identifiable and whether its members’ claims raised common issues. Once the excerpts qualified as public documents, however, the province bore the burden of showing why using them for those limited purposes would be unfair or unreliable.
Here, however, the province identified no specific statement that made the excerpts unsuitable for the purposes Cheekinew proposed. Leurer also noted that Saskatchewan itself cited both inquiries when it announced it would end birth alerts effective February 1, 2021.
The October 29 ruling allows the certification judge to assess the excerpts alongside the other evidence. It leaves open whether the proposed action qualifies for certification and whether the province is liable.



