
A Yukon judge has acquitted Liam Kearns of aggravated assault and assault with a weapon after finding that the Crown had not disproved self-defence beyond a reasonable doubt, despite the serious injuries and Kearns’ decision to bring a knife to the encounter.
In R. v. Kearns, 2026 YKSC 96, Justice K. Wenckebach examined the whole confrontation, including a surprise attack, a second participant and gaps in a video recording. The October 8 ruling did not excuse every choice Kearns made: bringing the knife and repeatedly using it weighed against him, but the evidence still left reasonable doubt.
The defence conceded that Kearns stabbed Tyler MacDougall, wounding him, and also stabbed Heather Belcher. The disputed issue was whether those acts were legally justified as self-defence.
A partial recording and uncertain memories
The confrontation occurred in an alleyway after Kearns’ relationship with Belcher had ended and she had begun a relationship with MacDougall, formerly Kearns’ close friend. Kearns went outside carrying a knife and approached Belcher, who was sitting in a car. MacDougall then grabbed him, and a fight followed. Belcher was stabbed by mistake during the encounter.
Three witnesses testified, and a video captured part of the fight. Kearns did not testify. The Crown introduced his police statement for the truth of its contents, allowing the judge to consider his account alongside the other evidence.
Wenckebach identified reliability problems across the record. MacDougall’s injuries, intoxication and the emotional intensity of the fight could explain inconsistent recollections. But his confidence about details later shown to be wrong made it difficult to know which parts were dependable. The judge was also concerned that watching the video and speaking with others had reshaped his memory.
The other two witnesses’ accounts were accepted only where corroborated. Kearns’ police statement was not accepted uncritically either. The judge found that he became more open as the interview progressed and made admissions against his interests, while remaining cautious about possible concealment or distortion.
Defensive purpose was established
Self-defence required a reasonable belief that force was being used against Kearns, a defensive purpose and a reasonable response in the circumstances. The Crown conceded the first element but contested the other two.
Before the defence could be considered, there had to be evidence capable of supporting an acquittal: an air of reality. Once that threshold was met, the Crown had to disprove at least one required element beyond a reasonable doubt.
On purpose, the Crown pointed to Kearns’ anger and his repeated use of the knife. The judge nevertheless found persuasive evidence that he acted to defend himself. MacDougall started the fight, Kearns did not draw the knife immediately, and his police statement repeatedly described fear of being hurt.
The judge accepted that Kearns went to the alleyway to speak with Belcher, not to fight MacDougall. His actions and attention were directed toward her. Carrying a knife showed awareness of possible danger, but did not establish that he knew MacDougall had come intending to fight him.
The fight was more than the video showed
The main dispute was whether using the knife was reasonable. For the preliminary air-of-reality assessment, the judge considered Kearns’ account on the assumption that the evidence he relied on was true. His description of a surprise attack, together with video evidence of another person joining the fight, cleared that threshold.
The final assessment was different. It required an objective examination of the entire incident, from the earlier communications to the end of the confrontation, rather than only the moment the knife was used.
Wenckebach rejected both sides’ broader explanations for how the fight began. The defence had not established a planned group ambush: claims about masks and a warning call rested on uncertain images and speculation. The Crown’s theory that MacDougall intervened to protect Belcher relied on an account of Kearns grabbing her hair that the judge did not accept.
Instead, the judge found that MacDougall had gone there intending to fight and assaulted Kearns while his attention was elsewhere. Another man helped MacDougall during the fight. The recording began after the confrontation was already underway, so it did not show everything that happened between the initial contact and the struggle on the ground.
Kearns may have been punched and dragged, although the judge could not be certain. His facial injuries were not adequately explained by MacDougall’s account. The evidence therefore left open the possibility of more violence against Kearns than appeared in the recorded segment.
The knife and repeated wounds still weighed against him
The court considered the nature of the force, Kearns’ role, the weapon, the parties’ relationship and the proportionality of his response. The surprise attack and involvement of a second person meant that the force used against him was not minor.
Kearns’ own conduct also mattered. He had brought a knife into a tense situation and may have approached Belcher aggressively. But assessing his role could not ignore MacDougall’s decision to start a fight. The judge rejected treating it as consensual combat.
Only Kearns was shown to have a weapon. There was little objective support for his belief that the others were armed, and no real evidence supporting the defence’s broader portrayal of them as violent people. Bringing the knife was foolish and weighed against him, even though the judge found it was carried for defensive purposes and used after he was attacked.
The repeated stabbings were especially serious evidence against the defence. Yet the record did not establish the complete sequence, the extent of force used against Kearns or the details needed to assess every wound. The fight ended shortly after MacDougall cried out, but the evidence did not resolve exactly when the wounds were inflicted or how Kearns reacted to their effect.
Wenckebach concluded that Kearns’ actions were not beyond reproach. Nevertheless, the Crown had not proved that his response was disproportionate or otherwise unreasonable beyond a reasonable doubt. The court entered not-guilty findings on both charges.
Source: R. v. Kearns, 2026 YKSC 96.



