
The Tax Court of Canada has dismissed an Ontario new-housing-rebate appeal after finding that evidence of occasional condominium use and changes to mailing records did not establish a settled intention to make the unit the purchaser’s primary home.
In Goncharova v. The King, Justice Perry Derksen focused on the purchaser’s intention when she assumed the purchase agreement through an assignment in November 2021. The judgment was issued September 18, 2026. Amended reasons signed September 24 corrected the date on the first page of the reasons.
Intention when the purchase obligation was assumed
The Ontario rebate rules incorporated the federal requirement that the purchaser acquire the property for use as a primary residence for herself or a relation. The dispute was not resolved simply by showing that someone had spent time in the unit.
The purchaser said the condominium would serve as the family home while plans to build another residence were delayed. The evidence included furniture purchases, photographs showing use, internet and insurance arrangements, changes to some mailing addresses and a driver’s-licence change.
The court acknowledged those steps rather than treating them as irrelevant. It nevertheless found that the broader pattern pointed elsewhere. The family continued renting a larger home throughout ownership of the condominium and after its sale. The judge rejected the explanation that the rental was retained mainly for storage. The location of ongoing schooling and the family’s daily arrangements also supported the rental property as the continuing home base.
Conduct outweighed the asserted plan
The judge applied established principles requiring objective evidence of a clear, settled intention to make the property a primary residence. Actual use could illuminate that intention, but a secondary residence or occasional accommodation did not satisfy the statutory purpose.
The decision did not hold that a small condominium could never serve as a family’s primary residence. The court expressly accepted that possibility, but found this purchaser’s explanation implausible when assessed against the continuing rental and surrounding circumstances.
The Crown did not pursue the separate first-occupancy condition in argument. The judge therefore decided the appeal on the primary-residence intention requirement, despite expressing reservations about the occupancy concession.
The appeal was dismissed without costs. The result is a fact-specific application of the rebate test, not a rule that address changes or furniture purchases can never support a claim.
Read the official reasons and order. This is an unofficial report of the decision.



