The Federal Court of Appeal has rejected a passenger’s attempt to revive a failed class-action certification motion against SATA Internacional – Azores Airlines, ruling that the issues had already been decided and that newer evidence did not justify reopening them.

In Berenguer v. SATA Internacional – Azores Airlines, S.A., 2026 FCA 154, delivered from the bench on September 16, 2026, the Court dismissed both Dora Berenguer’s appeal and her motion to introduce fresh evidence. Neither dismissal carried a costs award because the proceedings were related to the earlier certification proceedings.

A claim survived, but certification did not

The distinction between a viable individual claim and permission to proceed as a class action was central to the procedural history.

In 2021, the Federal Court struck Berenguer’s statement of claim for failing to disclose a reasonable cause of action. It also rejected certification because she had not met the requirement to show that a class proceeding was the preferable procedure for resolving the claims.

The Federal Court of Appeal reversed the order striking the claim in 2023, but upheld the refusal to certify. It found no error in the conclusion that Berenguer had not supplied evidence establishing that a class proceeding was preferable. The Supreme Court of Canada refused leave to appeal on April 11, 2024, and a reconsideration motion in the Federal Court of Appeal was also dismissed.

Berenguer then asked the Federal Court to determine whether she could bring a fresh certification motion. In June 2025, that court refused, relying on the finality doctrines of functus officio and issue estoppel. Those doctrines concern a court’s ability to revisit a completed decision and a party’s ability to relitigate an issue already decided.

Newer evidence did not reopen the earlier question

On the latest appeal, Berenguer sought to introduce evidence about proposed legislative changes and an increased complaints backlog at the Canadian Transportation Agency. Although that evidence had not been available during the original proceedings, the appeal court held that it did not meet the requirements for admitting fresh evidence.

The Court characterized the motion as an effort to repair the original lack of evidence five years after the certification decision. It stressed that the legislative changes relied on were proposed, rather than actual changes.

Berenguer also argued that the question of whether she could correct the evidentiary deficiency was a new remedial question, rather than the same question previously decided. The Court disagreed. The preferable-procedure requirement, and the evidence needed to meet it, had necessarily been before the Federal Court at certification. Issue estoppel can cover matters necessarily decided even when they were not expressly determined.

Class-action supervision does not override finality

The Court rejected the argument that the Supreme Court’s Sanis Health decision created an ongoing duty to protect class members that could overcome issue estoppel after certification had failed. That decision did not establish a new framework for reopening unsuccessful certification motions.

Nor did Federal Courts Rules 385 and 334.2 override issue estoppel. The Court found no error in the Federal Court’s treatment of those rules or its analysis of the finality doctrines.

The Court acknowledged that issue estoppel can be set aside in appropriate circumstances, including a material change in circumstances or new evidence. But the Federal Court had considered Berenguer’s arguments about changes in the agency’s dispute-resolution process, and the appeal court found no reviewable error in its refusal to make an exception.

The result leaves the refusal to permit a second certification motion in place. It does not decide the merits of the underlying passenger claim or establish that a failed certification motion can never be revisited. On this record, the claimed risk of injustice to potential class members did not outweigh the importance of finality.