The Federal Court of Appeal has overturned a tax ruling in favour of the Independent Order of Foresters, holding that the fraternal benefit society cannot use its tax-exempt accident-insurance business to reduce the income attributed to its taxable life-insurance business.

In Canada v. Independent Order of Foresters, 2026 FCA 146, released September 2, 2026, the court also required the Tax Court to reconsider the treatment of surplus assets using a different legal test. It allowed the Crown’s appeal with costs in both courts and set aside the Tax Court’s August 17, 2023 judgment.

The dispute is continuing. The Supreme Court of Canada’s docket records Foresters’ application for leave to appeal as completed on November 2, with receipt of a complete application acknowledged on November 5. No decision granting or refusing leave was shown when checked for this report.

Taxable insurance business within an exempt society

Foresters is a member-owned fraternal benefit society offering charitable, educational, social and volunteer activities as well as life, accident and sickness insurance. It is resident in Canada and has members in Canada, the United States and the United Kingdom.

Fraternal benefit societies generally have an income-tax exemption, but their life-insurance income is taxable. Subsection 149(4) of the Income Tax Act requires that taxable income to be calculated as if the society had no income or loss from other sources.

The case concerns the 2014 taxation year. Foresters then carried on life and accident-insurance businesses in Canada and the United States. Its accident business was winding down: accident premiums were $24,000, compared with $40.3 million in life-insurance premiums.

Another set of rules allocates investment income between Canada and foreign operations. A Canadian-resident multinational life insurer calculates a notional amount called its Canadian investment fund, then designates investment property whose income is included in its Canadian insurance income. The fund is a calculated number, not necessarily a separate pool of assets.

Two calculations the court rejected

Foresters included accident-business assets and their related liabilities when calculating its Canadian investment fund. Because the liabilities exceeded the assets, this reduced the fund by $3,299,000 and reduced the investment property needed to calculate investment revenue.

It also designated $199,462,344 of excess investment property to the accident-insurance business and treated the resulting investment revenue as exempt income. The excess arose because its calculated fund exceeded the property otherwise designated to cover its life and accident-insurance reserve liabilities.

The Tax Court accepted both approaches. The appeal court did not. Justices Siobhan Monaghan and Nathalie Goyette, with Justice David Stratas concurring, held that the statutory assumption applies throughout the calculation of taxable life-insurance income, including the investment-income calculation.

It was not enough to isolate life-insurance income only at the final stage of calculating taxable income. Foresters had to exclude accident-business items when calculating the life-insurance business’s Canadian investment fund, and the excess had to be designated to life insurance rather than accident insurance.

The court acknowledged that an ordinary multinational life insurer may choose which insurance business receives an excess designation under the regulations. That discretion was constrained here by the separate rule governing fraternal benefit societies.

The judges explained that the allocation system divides insurance investment income between Canada and other countries. It is not designed to shield Canadian life-insurance investment revenue from tax by assigning it to an exempt business.

Not every disputed designation was prohibited. Foresters could still designate $843,728 representing net mean Canadian reserve liabilities to its accident business. The resulting income remained exempt, but that designation could not change the taxable life-insurance calculation.

Surplus assets require a different starting point

The second major issue concerned assets labelled World Surplus, meaning surplus not allocated to a particular operation. Foresters argued that these assets were outside its insurance business and should be excluded from the Canadian investment fund.

The Tax Court had asked whether the assets were necessary to the insurance business or employed and risked in it. On that approach, it initially excluded surplus beyond the capital the business required, then considered whether particular uses justified bringing assets back into the calculation.

The appeal court said that reversed the statutory process. The correct starting point is to include every asset reported on the insurer’s non-consolidated year-end balance sheet. An asset may then be excluded only if the evidence establishes that it was not used or held in the insurance business at any time during the year. For Foresters, the analysis must focus on its life-insurance business.

Being unnecessary to immediate operations is not the same as never being held for the business. Nor does keeping an asset in a separate fund, or setting it aside for future growth, by itself establish the exclusion.

What remains for the Tax Court

The disputed surplus included $110,116,000 for 2013 and $217,025,000 for 2014, figures relevant to the investment-fund calculation. The court examined how the incorrect test affected the treatment of transfers between insurance divisions and World Surplus, assets supporting Foresters’ credit rating, and funds held for acquisitions, capital spending and growth.

For example, assets transferred out of an insurance division during a year may still have been held in that business earlier in the year. The test considers the whole year, not just the assets’ label at year-end.

The appeal court could not determine on the record which assets met the correct exclusion test. It therefore sent the matter back for re-examination and redetermination rather than fixing a final tax bill.

The ruling distinguishes exempt activities from the calculation of taxable life-insurance income and clarifies the burden for excluding assets from the statutory investment-fund formula. It does not eliminate Foresters’ exemption for its other activities or establish that every surplus asset must ultimately be taxed as part of its life-insurance business.