A company’s assertions that the Canada Revenue Agency overstated sales and understated input tax credits were not enough to frame a GST/HST appeal, the Tax Court of Canada has ruled.

Justice Ted Cook struck the notice of appeal filed by 10038555 Canada Limited but gave the company permission to file a replacement pleading. The August 21, 2026 order addressed the adequacy of the pleading, not the merits of the tax assessments.

Conclusions were not material facts

The company’s facts section said it manufactured custom stairs and railings, described the assessments as arbitrary, and asserted that sales, tax collectible and net tax were overstated while input tax credits were understated.

The company argued that those statements were clear and concise enough for the Crown to answer. The Crown moved under section 53 of the General Procedure rules to strike the pleading with leave to amend.

The judge found that the description of the company’s business was its only pleaded material fact. The assertions about tax liability and credits were conclusions the court was being asked to reach. They did not supply the underlying facts needed for the Crown to prepare its reply.

Discovery does not repair the starting point

The reasons distinguished material facts from the evidence that would eventually prove them. A pleading must identify the essential facts concisely, rather than recite all the evidence, but it must still explain the factual basis of the dispute.

The court rejected the suggestion that document review during discovery would solve the problem. Pleadings define the issues and establish what information is relevant to discovery and trial; the opposing party needs that framework before those steps occur.

The company also invoked the demanding test for striking a claim that discloses no reasonable cause of action. The judge explained that a pleading can separately be struck when its lack of material facts prevents the respondent from knowing how to answer and may prejudice or delay a fair hearing.

A chance to plead again

The order gave the company 60 days from the order date to file a fresh amended notice setting out its material facts. The Crown’s reply was due 60 days after that filing. Costs were awarded to the Crown regardless of the eventual outcome of the appeal.

The ruling did not dismiss the underlying assessment challenge outright or establish that the CRA’s calculations were correct. It required a properly pleaded factual dispute before the litigation could move forward.

Read the official reasons and order. This is an unofficial report of the decision.