
The Tax Court has rejected the Crown’s attempt to remove substantial portions of United Health Services Corporation’s tax appeal, cautioning that a motion to strike should not become an exercise in editing an opponent’s wording.
Justice J. Scott Bodie’s July 30 ruling leaves the corporation’s pleading intact and awards it $5,000 in costs. It does not decide whether United Health Services Corporation qualifies for the non-profit tax exemption it claims for 2020 and 2021.
Pandemic years form the underlying dispute
The corporation appeals reassessments on the basis that it falls within paragraph 149(1)(l) of the Income Tax Act. Its case is that it was created under Manitoba legislation for public-benefit purposes and did not operate for profit.
According to its pleaded position, the pandemic years were unusual: revenue continued while the cost of services declined. It says its history, provincial relationship, reserves and subsequent losses provide context for assessing its purpose. Those remain allegations to be tested in the tax appeal, not factual conclusions adopted by the motions judge.
The Crown sought to strike passages as irrelevant, legal argument improperly placed among facts, or scandalous, frivolous or vexatious. It also challenged statutory references and the corporation’s stated reasons for appealing.
Events outside the assessment years can provide relevant context
The judge rejected the proposition that pleaded facts must necessarily be confined to events within the two taxation years under appeal. The organization’s origins and operations before and after the pandemic could bear on whether it was organized and operated for a qualifying non-profit purpose.
Similarly, its relationship with Manitoba could be relevant. The court did not finally determine the significance of those facts; it held that their irrelevance was not plain and obvious at this preliminary stage. The trial judge would assess the evidence.
Imperfect wording did not meet the striking threshold
The Crown also objected to descriptions of the corporation as a non-profit organization within the facts section. The court distinguished a taxpayer’s factual pleading from the Minister’s pleaded assumptions, which carry a presumption the taxpayer must overcome.
Even if a description combined law and fact or would be more accurately phrased as a claim to non-profit treatment, the parties understood the issue. The judge did not find obvious prejudice, delay or another ground for striking it.
The same approach applied to language alleging that the reassessments were erroneous and to more accusatory passages. The court considered some wording colourful and said the points could have been made more dispassionately. But disagreement over wording was not enough to justify judicial intervention.
The ruling does not authorize the Tax Court to review ministerial misconduct as an independent ground for relief. It found that the challenged wording did not expand this particular appeal beyond the correctness of the assessments.
Discovery and particulars can clarify the case
The court also left additional statutory references, including a reference to the Constitution Act, 1867, in place. Some tax provisions had apparently appeared in the reassessments, and their relevance could become clearer after the Crown filed its reply and discovery proceeded.
The judge emphasized other procedural tools, including demands for particulars, discovery and any required constitutional notice, rather than premature removal of potentially relevant material. No constitutional claim or exemption argument was decided on its merits.
The Crown was ordered to pay the $5,000 costs by September 1, 2026 and was given 60 days from the July order to file its reply. The decision concerns the sufficiency of the pleading, not a final victory on the corporation’s tax liability.
Read the official reasons and order. This is an unofficial report.



