Using a former apartment to store business inventory did not make it eligible for pandemic rent subsidies, the Tax Court has ruled in a case that turned on the property's residential character rather than the owner's asserted commercial use.

Justice John Sorensen dismissed E Poly International's appeal on July 9. The ruling upheld the denial of Canada Emergency Rent Subsidy claims and claims under its successor Hardest-Hit Businesses Recovery Program, without costs.

Inventory storage did not change the apartment's character

The business was a sole proprietorship operated by Poly Elei, who brokered used car parts and also drove for Uber. He claimed rent expenses for an apartment and later expenses associated with a home he co-owned.

For the first two rent-subsidy periods, the apartment was his residence. For the next five, he said he had moved out but continued renting it solely to store car parts. Inventory was later moved to the house, which formed the basis of the successor-program claims.

The Income Tax Act's definition of qualifying property excludes a self-contained domestic establishment used by the eligible entity or a non-arm's-length person, as well as parts of that residential property. The judge held that simply changing what the apartment was used for did not remove it from this exclusion.

The apartment remained a purpose-built residential living space even if Elei no longer slept or ate there. The statutory exclusion did not specify that the taxpayer had to use the apartment as a residence during the claim period.

Separate commercial space remains a different question

The reasons did not rule out every mixed-use property. A genuinely separate commercial area in a mixed-use building might qualify, such as a store distinct from a proprietor's apartment. The judge also acknowledged that a material change involving zoning, structure and leasing arrangements could potentially change a property's character.

Neither possibility was established here. Storing parts in the later house likewise involved part of a domestic establishment, with no factual basis to separate a qualifying commercial portion. The property findings were enough to decide the appeal.

A revenue decline also needed evidence

The court identified a separate evidentiary problem. Elei could not reliably separate income from the parts business from his driving income. Available driving statements and bank records did not establish the parts business's qualifying revenue decline.

Although his driving income appeared to have declined during the pandemic, the subsidy claims concerned property used for the parts business. An unsupported estimate of how his income was divided did not establish entitlement.

Elei also said CRA staff had advised him that he qualified. The judge distinguished an assessment appeal, which determines statutory entitlement, from judicial review of a discretionary administrative decision. Alleged advice and good-faith use of the funds did not overcome the legislation's requirements.

The decision concerns eligibility for the historical claim periods before the court, not a determination that ordinary home-office expenses can never be deductible for other tax purposes.

Read the official judgment and reasons. This is an unofficial report.