
The Tax Court has refused to let a corporation’s non-lawyer manager represent it in a General Procedure appeal, finding that an assertion of financial hardship without supporting evidence did not establish the special circumstances required.
In Stinson School Inc. v. The King, Justice John A. Sorensen also found that the proposed representative had not demonstrated the ability to manage the litigation or prepare it for trial. The July 7 order denied the representation motion without costs; it did not dismiss the underlying tax appeal.
Complex reassessments and an unfinished timetable
The corporation’s appeal concerned reassessments for 2015 and 2016 involving adjustments approaching $7 million. It disputed reassessment beyond the normal period and gross-negligence penalties, creating additional questions about which party bore the burden of proof.
After the corporation’s lawyer withdrew, it did not meet further timetable obligations. Harry Stinson proposed to represent it, saying the company could not afford counsel and that his familiarity with the facts made him the logical person to conduct the appeal.
Only the notice of motion was filed before the hearing. No affidavit, written submissions or authorities were supplied, and no supporting material was added at the hearing.
Corporate representation differs from an individual appearing alone
The judge distinguished an individual’s ability to appear personally from a corporation’s position. A corporation is a separate legal person that must act through a representative. For General Procedure matters, counsel is the statutory default.
The legislation permits the court, in special circumstances, to grant leave for representation by a director, officer, employee, member or partner. The court assesses financial impediments to retaining counsel, the proposed representative’s capacity to act effectively and the ability to prepare the case for trial.
Financial difficulty alone is not decisive. The moving party must establish the relevant circumstances with evidence, and the court must also consider efficient proceedings and compliance with procedural and evidence rules.
Knowledge of the facts was not enough
The court could not assess the claimed inability to pay because no financial documentation supported it. The judge also found that the deficient motion materials raised substantial doubts about the proposed representative’s ability to handle more demanding stages such as discovery, undertakings, evidentiary objections and trial preparation.
The reassessment-period and penalty issues added legal complexity. There were also concerns about combining the roles of advocate and witness, given Stinson’s direct familiarity with the events and potential involvement of related witnesses.
The judge described the proposed representative’s efforts as good-faith efforts, but concluded that the statutory exception had not been established. The ruling is not a finding that corporations can never obtain permission for non-lawyer representation.
Order required counsel, not immediate dismissal
The July order directed the corporation to appoint counsel by September 1, 2026 and to bring a motion addressing the litigation timetable by October 2 after consulting the Crown. It warned that failure to appoint counsel could lead to a show-cause hearing at which the appeal might be dismissed.
That warning was conditional. The decision did not decide the corporation’s tax liability, and this report does not establish whether it subsequently retained counsel or complied with the timetable.
Read the official reasons and order. This is an unofficial report.



