
IWK Health Centre and Nova Scotia Health Authority have lost their appeal seeking tax rebates for reimbursements of employees’ personal healthcare expenses.
In IWK Health Centre v. Canada, 2026 FCA 113, delivered from the bench on June 11, 2026, the Federal Court of Appeal upheld the Tax Court’s refusal to disturb the assessments. The Court dismissed the consolidated appeals with one set of costs to the Crown.
A rebate depended on a connection to the employer’s activities
The health employers sought rebates available to selected public service bodies under subsection 259(3) of the Excise Tax Act. The reimbursements concerned services including acupuncture, massage therapy, naturopathy and homeopathy.
The calculation depended in part on tax treated by section 175 as having been paid by the employer. That provision requires an employee to acquire a service for consumption or use in relation to the employer’s activities, pay the applicable tax, and receive reimbursement from the employer.
The Tax Court held that the services were personal to the employees who purchased them. The employers’ contractual obligation to reimburse those costs did not provide a sufficient connection to their activities to overcome that personal character. The Minister had therefore properly disallowed the rebates in dispute.
The appeal challenged precedent, not the factual distinction
The employers did not try to distinguish their circumstances from the Federal Court of Appeal’s earlier ExxonMobil and Westcoast Energy decisions. Instead, they argued that those decisions were manifestly wrong and should no longer be followed.
That required more than persuading a new panel to prefer a different interpretation of the legislation. Under the Court’s Miller precedent, an earlier decision must generally be followed unless it can be distinguished or it overlooked a relevant statutory provision or a case that should have been followed.
The Court found that none of the employers’ arguments met that threshold. Claims that the earlier decisions produced absurd results or were inconsistent with one another amounted to disagreement with their interpretation, rather than identification of a qualifying omission.
The Court also rejected the argument that the earlier judgments had overlooked the statutory scheme. ExxonMobil had considered section 174 in detail alongside other provisions. Westcoast had held that its interpretation applied equally to section 175, and that equal application was not disputed in these appeals.
A pension-plan decision did not change the result
The employers relied on General Motors of Canada, an earlier decision that neither ExxonMobil nor Westcoast had expressly mentioned. But the absence of a citation did not establish that the case had been overlooked.
General Motors concerned section 169 and expenses incurred by an employer for an employee pension plan and later charged to the plan. The other cases involved employees incurring expenses and then receiving reimbursement: moving allowances in ExxonMobil and healthcare costs similar to those at issue here in Westcoast.
The Court found that those differences reasonably explained why General Motors had not been discussed. It remained bound by ExxonMobil and Westcoast.
The decision leaves the denial of these particular rebates in place. It does not decide whether the employees were entitled to reimbursement under their employment arrangements, or address the clinical merits of the services. Its focus is the statutory tax connection and the demanding threshold for departing from binding appellate precedent.



