
The Federal Court of Appeal has upheld a stay in favour of California arbitration and the refusal to certify a proposed class action challenging Ooma’s advertising of its internet telephone service as free or costing $0, with fees and taxes payable.
In Zanin v. Ooma, Inc., 2026 FCA 98, decided May 19, 2026, the court dismissed the customer’s appeal without costs. It found no reversible error in enforcing the arbitration arrangement or in the lower court’s assessment of the pleaded misleading-advertising claim.
The litigation is not necessarily over. The Supreme Court of Canada docket records an application for leave to appeal filed August 18 and completed August 20, with further filings in September and October. At this report’s November 15 check, the public docket did not record a leave decision.
A service advertised with fees payable
Ontario resident John Zanin subscribed to Ooma’s Voice over Internet Protocol service in January 2020 after seeing an advertisement in a Costco magazine. Monthly fees often ranged between $5 and $6 and formed part of Ooma’s revenues. He cancelled the subscription in December 2021.
The proposed class action began with a different representative plaintiff in February 2021. It alleged that describing the service as free misrepresented its real cost, advancing misleading-advertising and double-ticketing claims under the Competition Act and a false-description claim under the Trademarks Act.
Zanin replaced the original representative plaintiff in November 2021. The proceedings were deemed to have begun on November 8 of that year.
Ooma relied from the outset on its contractual dispute-resolution terms. Those terms provided for arbitration in Santa Clara County under JAMS rules, included a class-action waiver, and designated local courts for litigation if part of the arbitration agreement proved unenforceable.
The Federal Court stayed the proceeding in January 2025 and dismissed the certification motion for failing to disclose a reasonable cause of action. On appeal, Zanin challenged the stay and the misleading-advertising conclusion, but did not pursue the separate double-ticketing and trademark claims.
Seeking alternative relief did not waive arbitration
Zanin did not dispute that he had accepted the terms or that competition and trademark claims could generally be arbitrated. His central objection was that Ooma had surrendered its arbitration rights by asking, in the alternative, for summary judgment if the court refused a stay.
The appeal court rejected that argument. Case-management orders had expressly preserved Ooma’s jurisdictional objections while allowing specified procedural steps. Ooma repeatedly maintained those objections, and the same judge who issued the protective orders found the company had stayed within them.
Whether a party has accepted a court’s jurisdiction or waived arbitration depends on the circumstances. The appeal court found no palpable and overriding error in the judge’s assessment of the orders, pleadings and parties’ intentions. The result was not a general licence to seek any court remedy while preserving arbitration; the protective orders mattered.
New B.C. provisions did not govern this claim
Zanin also relied on British Columbia consumer-protection provisions restricting arbitration clauses and class-action waivers that came into force on March 31, 2025.
The court was not persuaded that his claim had a substantial connection to that province. He was an Ontario consumer. Although Ooma Canada was incorporated in British Columbia, he had not established that this administratively focused subsidiary supplied the service for the purposes of the provincial legislation.
In any event, the court held that those provisions did not apply retroactively to his earlier claim.
A further argument concerned alleged incompatibility between the arbitration clause and JAMS policies. The appeal court held that the fact-dependent issue belonged initially to the arbitrator under the principle that arbitrators ordinarily decide their own jurisdiction. Zanin had not established an applicable exception, and had supplied no expert evidence about the relevant California law.
The court also rejected the suggestion that the federal statutory damages remedy prevented arbitration. Because the class-action-waiver challenge was tied to the arbitration challenge rather than advanced independently, upholding arbitration was sufficient to dispose of the appeal.
Court also addressed the advertising allegations
The panel nevertheless considered the misleading-advertising arguments because the dispute might continue through arbitration or further litigation.
The lower court had found that the allegations did not fairly reproduce Ooma’s promotional materials, which expressly stated that fees and taxes remained payable. The appeal court declined to substitute a different reading of the record and found no reversible error in the conclusion that the pleaded claim had no reasonable prospect of success under the applicable version of section 52.
Zanin argued that expert evidence was needed to assess the general impression conveyed to consumers. The appeal court held that expert evidence may assist in some cases, but is not invariably required. Treating it as mandatory would undermine the court’s preliminary responsibility to decide whether a proposed claim is legally viable.
The court also declined to interfere with the refusal to receive further submissions about the Competition Act’s express drip-pricing provision, enacted June 23, 2022, after Zanin stopped using the service. It accepted the lower court’s non-retroactivity conclusion and its assessment of the usefulness of further submissions in the case as pleaded.
The decision therefore does not provide a blanket endorsement of advertising a price that excludes mandatory charges under today’s legislation. It concerns this contractual record, these pleadings and the law applicable to the earlier subscription period, with a request for Supreme Court review still on the public docket.



