
The Federal Court of Appeal has upheld an order requiring the Crown to contribute 60% of Marine Atlantic’s legal fees after tax litigation marked by delayed concessions and last-minute evidence.
In Canada v. Marine Atlantic, 2026 FCA 96, released May 13, 2026, the court dismissed the Crown’s challenge to the enhanced costs award. It also awarded Marine Atlantic $3,020 in all-inclusive costs for the appeal, as the parties had agreed.
The ruling concerns the cost consequences of how the tax case was litigated. It did not reopen the ferry operator’s successful underlying tax appeals or impose a fixed percentage for every case involving government delay.
A tax dispute about shared ferry expenses
Marine Atlantic, a federal Crown corporation, provides passenger and commercial ferry transportation between Newfoundland and Labrador and Nova Scotia. Its underlying appeals concerned GST/HST input tax credits for expenses used to make both taxable and exempt supplies.
The ferry service itself was exempt, while upgraded accommodation and sales of goods, food and beverages were taxable. Marine Atlantic used a vessel-area allocation method to determine how much of its costs related to taxable activities.
The Crown challenged aspects of how the formula treated terminals, exterior decks and fuel. The Tax Court ultimately accepted Marine Atlantic’s approach and allowed the appeals in 2023.
After the hearing judge retired, another judge decided the merits on the transcripts, documentary evidence and written submissions, with the parties’ agreement and a further appearance to summarize arguments and answer questions. That judge later made the costs award under appeal.
The amounts in issue in the underlying tax appeals were between $19.7 million and $21.8 million. Those figures were not the costs award. Both sides accepted that enhanced costs were appropriate, but the Crown proposed no more than 30% of reasonable legal fees, plus supported necessary disbursements. Marine Atlantic sought more.
Delayed concessions led to unnecessary work
One central issue was a 2013 agreement concerning another ferry-tax case, BC Ferries. The Tax Court found that the parties had agreed to be bound by its findings on common issues.
The BC Ferries decision, released in October 2014, classified upgraded accommodation as exclusively taxable and vessel infrastructure as common areas used for taxable and exempt activities.
Despite repeated requests from Marine Atlantic, the Crown maintained contrary positions until November 2020 and did not file its concession letter until September 2021, just before the hearing. The Tax Court found that the delay caused expensive and ultimately unnecessary work measuring common areas of the vessels.
On appeal, the Crown argued that the agreement bound only Marine Atlantic. The appeal court rejected that challenge. A 2016 Tax Court decision had already interpreted the agreement, using both its wording and surrounding circumstances, as reflecting the parties’ intention to be bound on the common issues. The Crown had not appealed that decision.
The Crown therefore failed to show an obvious error affecting the result in the later costs finding. Asking the appeal court to reassess the evidence was not enough.
Admitting evidence did not erase its cost consequences
The second central issue concerned an affidavit from a CRA specialist, offered immediately after Marine Atlantic finished presenting its evidence. It had been sworn nine days earlier and carried 90 pages of documents that had not been identified in the pleadings, supplied on discovery or informally shared before Marine Atlantic closed its case.
The hearing was adjourned and the parties made written submissions about admissibility. They eventually agreed that Marine Atlantic would withdraw its objection in exchange for being allowed to recall witnesses. The hearing judge then admitted the affidavit.
The Tax Court nevertheless found that the manner of introducing it amounted to an attempt at trial by ambush. It resulted in lost hearing days, further submissions and additional testimony, with argument delayed from October 2021 to January 2022.
The Crown acknowledged on appeal that the late filing prolonged the trial and caused expense. It also accepted that deterring a repetition of that conduct was a legitimate purpose of a costs award.
But it argued that the judge had improperly punished the Crown for using affidavits generally, including in unrelated cases. Justice Gerald Heckman’s unanimous reasons rejected that reading. The award was directed at the conduct in Marine Atlantic’s case, both compensating for added expense and discouraging similar behaviour, rather than punishing the Crown for a broader practice.
The appeal court did caution judges against using reasons to express general views about litigation trends or conduct in other proceedings. Those observations should not replace findings grounded in the evidence and issues actually before the court. Here, however, the wider comments did not undermine the specific basis for the award.
Why the 60% award stood
Costs decisions involve considerable discretion. The legal scope of the relevant factors is reviewed for correctness, while their application to the facts generally requires a palpable and overriding error before an appeal court may intervene.
The Tax Court considered the successful result, the amounts involved, the work required and the Crown’s conduct. The Crown also argued that the judge had to justify the percentage by comparing awards in similar cases.
The appeal court rejected a rigid comparison requirement. Earlier authority had criticized a judge for choosing a restricted range without an adequate basis, thereby limiting the available discretion. It did not establish that every principled costs award required a comparative survey.
The court found nothing unprincipled in the application of the relevant factors to this record. The 60% contribution therefore remained in place, with the additional $3,020 appeal costs.
The decision preserves a distinction between punishment and legitimate compensation and deterrence. It also shows that evidence may be admitted while the way it was introduced still carries costs consequences. The ruling does not declare affidavits generally improper or require full reimbursement of a successful litigant’s fees.



