The Supreme Court of Canada upheld Moadd Maadani’s second-degree murder conviction on April 17, 2026, rejecting his attempt to introduce new eyewitness evidence supporting his claim of self-defence. Two dissenting judges would have admitted the evidence and ordered a new trial.

In R. v. Maadani, 2026 SCC 11, the five-judge majority found no reviewable error in the Ontario Court of Appeal’s rejection of the evidence for lack of cogency. The dispute concerned how closely an appeal court should scrutinize a witness’s credibility before allowing evidence that a jury never heard.

Maadani had been convicted of killing Ryan Kabuya-Ntumba during an exchange of gunfire in Ottawa in July 2019. His sentence was life imprisonment without eligibility for parole for 14 years. The Supreme Court’s dismissal left that conviction standing; it did not order a retrial.

An eyewitness comes forward after trial

Maadani fired five shots, while Kabuya-Ntumba fired once and wounded him in the leg. The defence argued that Maadani responded to lethal force. The Crown argued both that Maadani initiated the gunfight and that he continued shooting after Kabuya-Ntumba was on the ground and no longer a threat.

Security video captured the confrontation, but its images were poor and it had no sound. Who fired first remained contested: only four muzzle flashes from Maadani’s five shots were visible, leaving the parties with competing explanations of the unseen shot’s place in the sequence.

After trial, Brightner Casseus, an associate of Kabuya-Ntumba who was present during the confrontation, offered an account supporting Maadani. He said Kabuya-Ntumba had expressed aggression toward Maadani and had drawn and fired his gun first. He had not testified at trial and swore his affidavit almost four years after the shooting, without first watching the video.

The proposed evidence also included an affidavit from trial counsel’s law clerk explaining why the defence had not pursued Casseus. Counsel knew his identity but had no contact information or leads and thought an associate of the deceased was unlikely to cooperate or help the defence.

Why the evidence was rejected

Appeal courts may receive fresh evidence when the interests of justice warrant it. The framework considers ordinary evidentiary admissibility, cogency and the explanation for failing to present the evidence at trial. Cogency asks whether the evidence concerns a potentially decisive issue, is reasonably capable of belief and could reasonably have affected the result when considered with the trial record.

The Crown did not dispute ordinary admissibility or relevance to self-defence. Credibility was the central dividing point.

Writing for the Ontario majority, Justice Grant Huscroft found Casseus’s account not reasonably capable of belief. He considered the witness’s extensive criminal record, including dishonesty offences, his uncertain memory and significant inconsistencies with the video. Those inconsistencies appeared to minimize Casseus’s own involvement while blaming the deceased, the judge said.

The majority identified four main conflicts: an alleged earlier armed chase that the video did not show; how the groups came together; Casseus’s claimed efforts to restrain Kabuya-Ntumba immediately before the shooting; and whether Casseus was looking toward the gunfire when he said he saw it. Huscroft concluded that the problems went beyond peripheral mistakes.

His reasons stressed that appeal judges must assess whether evidence could reasonably be believed without deciding its ultimate credibility. In his view, finality required more scrutiny than simply asking whether some trier of fact might accept it.

In an addendum, the Ontario majority concluded that the new evidence could not reasonably be expected to affect the verdict. Even evidence that Kabuya-Ntumba fired first would not resolve whether Maadani’s repeated shots were a reasonable response, and Casseus had not seen every shot. It also rejected the defence’s diligence explanation, reasoning that Maadani knew about the witness but chose not to pursue him because he assumed the evidence would not help.

The Supreme Court majority’s brief oral reasons expressly upheld the cogency ruling. They did not separately endorse every aspect of the Ontario majority’s due-diligence analysis.

Dissenters would have let a new jury assess the account

Justices Andromache Karakatsanis and Suzanne Côté concluded that the Ontario majority had crossed the line into deciding the witness’s ultimate credibility. They also found an error in its treatment of due diligence. They agreed with Ontario dissenting Justice Jill Copeland that a trier of fact could reasonably believe the new evidence on key self-defence issues.

Copeland accepted that Casseus had credibility problems. But his presence at the scene was undisputed, and there was no evidence of a motive to favour Maadani. His criminal record did not make belief impossible. Memory gaps years later had to be assessed for their significance, and he was a new witness, not someone recanting earlier trial testimony.

She also found parts of his account supported by the video. Some discrepancies could reflect confusion about sequencing rather than fabrication. A frame-by-frame analysis risked distorting what he could observe in real time, and the silent recording could not resolve his account of verbal threats. Because he had not watched the video before giving his affidavit, its points of agreement mattered.

Copeland agreed that who fired first was not decisive by itself. But it could change the assessment of whether Maadani’s response was reasonable during a shooting that unfolded in roughly four to five seconds. The forensic evidence also allowed different interpretations of Kabuya-Ntumba’s body position when he was shot.

On diligence, she emphasized flexibility in criminal cases and the seriousness of excluding potentially important evidence in a murder appeal. Counsel’s failure to locate Casseus was reasonable in the circumstances, she found, and was not a tactical decision to avoid harmful evidence: interviewing him would not have obliged counsel to call him. Nor was his account interchangeable with testimony Maadani could have given, since it came from an associate of the deceased and included earlier statements unknown to Maadani.

Other Ontario challenges had also failed

The Ontario court unanimously rejected challenges to the jury instructions. Read as a whole, the charge properly focused self-defence on Maadani’s state of mind when he fired. Instructions about his flight and false account of his injury required the jury to reject other reasonable explanations before drawing an inference against self-defence; they excluded using that conduct to determine intent or provocation.

The Ontario majority also rejected his sentence appeal, citing the danger of repeated gunfire on a crowded street and finding the 14-year parole-ineligibility period not demonstrably unfit. These were separate aspects of the lower-court decision. The Supreme Court’s stated disagreement centred on the new evidence, with the majority leaving the verdict undisturbed.