The Federal Court of Appeal has refused to increase the Crown’s costs recovery against two taxpayers by counting the financial stakes in unrelated appeals waiting for their case to be decided.

In Canada v. Vefghi Holding Corporation, 2026 FCA 70, the court awarded the Crown one set of tariff costs for the Tax Court proceeding and one set for the appeal, with Vefghi Holding Corporation and S.O.N.S. Environmental Ltd. each responsible for half. The April 10 costs ruling followed the Crown’s successful appeal in 2025 FCA 143.

A preliminary tax question and a later costs dispute

The underlying proceeding used Rule 58 to determine when corporations must be connected for Part IV income-tax purposes where a dividend passes through a trust and is designated to a corporate beneficiary. The Tax Court had ordered each party to bear its own costs.

On appeal, the court supplied an answer substantially closer to the Crown’s position, although it did not adopt that position exactly. The Crown then sought 45 per cent of its solicitor-client costs for the Tax Court proceeding and tariff costs for the appeal.

The taxpayers sought no costs award, or alternatively a return of the lower-court costs question to the Tax Court. Because the judge who decided the preliminary question had retired, the appeal court decided the costs issue itself.

Other taxpayers’ liabilities were not these taxpayers’ stakes

The Crown relied on the amounts involved, the importance of the issues, the volume of work and complexity. Together, Vefghi and S.O.N.S. disputed $1,110,338 in federal Part IV tax. The court noted the potentially refundable nature of that tax, but neither side addressed how that feature should affect the amounts-in-issue factor.

The Crown also pointed to appeals held in abeyance and argued that their aggregate stakes should be considered to encourage efficient use of lead cases. The court distinguished precedents in which successful taxpayers recovered costs from the Crown, which is a party to every tax appeal and can benefit directly from resolving several disputes through a lead case.

Here, neither Vefghi nor S.O.N.S. was a party to the other appeals, and no relationship to those taxpayers had been shown. Each company’s relevant stake was its own assessment: $454,428 for Vefghi and $655,910 for S.O.N.S. There was no indication either was liable for the other’s assessment or for assessments against other taxpayers.

A separate precedent relied on by the Crown involved additional appeals by the same taxpayer or members of the same corporate group. That did not establish a basis for increasing costs against these companies.

Success warranted costs, but not an enhancement

The court also found that the importance, workload and complexity identified by the Crown did not justify exceeding the tariff. Novelty, difficulty, substantial stakes and legal fees exceeding tariff recovery do not by themselves require enhanced costs.

But the taxpayers provided no support for departing from the ordinary rule that a successful party receives costs. Because their appeals involved the same arguments, the Crown would recover only one set at each level, shared equally between the companies.

In a subsequent development, the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the application for leave to appeal the underlying 2025 merits judgment on August 6, 2026, with costs. That leave disposition concerned 2025 FCA 143, not a new merits determination in this separate costs ruling.