The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled that an Ontario couple cannot pursue their claims against three Italian companies in Ontario over a Venice water-taxi accident, finding that a travel booking arranged through an Ontario credit-card concierge service did not create a strong enough connection to the province.

The 5–4 decision in Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo, 2025 SCC 27, delivered July 31, 2025, upheld the stay of the action against Venezia Turismo, Venice Limousine and Narduzzi E Solemar. The ruling concerned where those claims could be heard, not whether anyone was negligent or owed damages.

Justice Suzanne Côté, writing for the majority, accepted that the couple’s Ontario cardmember agreement could initially support a presumption of jurisdiction. But the Italian companies rebutted that presumption: the agreement’s connection to the dispute was too weak. Four dissenting judges said the majority overlooked the pleaded chain of negligent hiring and transportation services linking the accident to Ontario contracts.

A concierge booking followed by a crash

Duncan and Michelle Sinclair, Ontario residents, travelled to Europe with their son in 2017. Duncan’s Centurion card provided access to Amex Canada’s concierge and travel services. While in Florence, he contacted an Amex agent in Toronto to arrange transportation from Venice’s airport to the family’s hotel, including a water taxi.

Amex contacted Carey International, which sent a reservation confirmation to Amex. The confirmation was forwarded to Duncan. During the journey, the water taxi struck a wooden structure, seriously injuring him.

The Sinclairs sued several defendants in Ontario, including Amex, Carey, the driver and the three Italian companies. Their negligence allegations extended beyond the driving itself to the selection of transportation providers and responsibility for others’ conduct. Those allegations had not been decided at trial.

The three companies challenged Ontario’s jurisdiction. A Superior Court judge allowed the claims to proceed, but the Ontario Court of Appeal stayed the action against them. Amex and Carey had accepted Ontario’s jurisdiction; their position did not determine whether Ontario could hear the claims against the companies contesting it.

An Ontario contract is a starting point

The dispute turned on the framework established in Club Resorts Ltd. v. Van Breda. For a tort claim involving another province or country, a plaintiff can establish a presumptive connection to the court’s province by showing that a contract connected with the dispute was made there.

That is only the first step. A defendant can rebut the presumption by showing that the connection between the dispute and the province is absent or weak. The majority emphasized the distinction between identifying a connection and evaluating its strength. Jurisdiction must be assessed for each defendant who contests it.

The defendant need not be a party to the Ontario contract. Nor must the lawsuit itself seek damages for breach of that contract. Events giving rise to a negligence claim can flow from the relationship the contract created. But treating a series of arrangements as an undifferentiated collection of contracts can obscure whether any particular contract was actually formed in Ontario and connected to the dispute.

Côté said the pleadings must provide enough detail to support contract formation, including offer, acceptance and consideration, unless those elements are apparent from the circumstances. Pleaded facts generally are accepted unless contradicted by evidence, but a bare legal conclusion about a contract does not establish the necessary connection.

The majority found one presumptive connection

Although the cardmember agreement itself was not in evidence and the majority considered the pleadings sparse, Côté proceeded on the basis that it was made in Ontario. The booking arose through the relationship it created, satisfying the initial connecting factor.

The majority rejected the suggestion that asking Amex to make this particular reservation created a separate Ontario contract with Amex. Arranging travel was performance of the existing cardmember agreement; the record did not establish a new bargain supported by additional consideration.

It also found that a separate booking contract between Amex and Carey had not been established. On the majority’s reading, Amex acted as the Sinclairs’ agent, and the record did not establish the necessary bargain and consideration for the alleged contract. Nor did the record establish that a contract for the actual water-taxi transportation was made in Ontario. Côté considered the possibility of such a contract being made at the dock in Italy, without needing a definitive finding on that point.

These distinctions mattered because the cardmember agreement was the only Ontario contract the majority accepted as supporting presumptive jurisdiction. It still had to withstand the companies’ rebuttal.

Why the connection was too weak

For the majority, the cardmember agreement provided general travel-related services rather than the specific transportation involved in the accident. The reservation made through Amex and Carey connected that agreement to the trip, but did not supply a sufficiently substantial connection between Ontario and the claims against the Italian companies.

Côté emphasized the circumstances of the Italian service: the taxi was owned and dispatched by Italian companies, operated in Italy and procured while Duncan was there. The companies had no relationship with Amex and no demonstrated awareness that an Ontario cardmember agreement lay behind the booking.

The majority considered the defendants’ objectively reasonable expectations relevant to assessing whether a connection was too weak. It warned against exposing foreign providers to Ontario litigation simply because customers arranged their services through an Ontario credit-card agreement. That analysis remained contextual; it did not establish that a foreign accident can never be litigated in Ontario.

The court also distinguished this inquiry from forum non conveniens, the separate doctrine allowing a court that has jurisdiction to decline to exercise it because another forum is clearly more appropriate. The Supreme Court appeal concerned the existence of jurisdiction, not that later discretionary choice.

Dissent focused on the alleged chain of negligence

Justice Mahmud Jamal, joined by Justices Andromache Karakatsanis, Sheilah Martin and Nicholas Kasirer, would have restored the motion judge’s order.

Jamal said Ontario’s established procedural threshold required only a good arguable case for the facts supporting jurisdiction. Such motions arise before discovery and a complete evidentiary record. Uncontradicted pleaded facts must be accepted, and a jurisdiction motion should not become a trial of the underlying claim.

The majority acknowledged a low threshold but declined to settle the precise role of the good-arguable-case standard, an issue the parties had not challenged. Jamal considered its application settled in Ontario and essential to deciding this appeal.

In his view, the pleadings and Amex’s admissions supported two Ontario contracts: the cardmember agreement and Amex’s agreement with Carey for the booking. The motion judge’s findings about the latter agreement, including receipt of acceptance in Toronto, deserved appellate deference. This contrasted with the majority’s treatment of the contract-formation issues as legal errors open to correction.

More fundamentally, Jamal said the dispute could not be reduced to negligent driving in Italy. The Sinclairs alleged an integrated sequence of negligent engagement of service providers and negligent transportation, flowing from their reliance on Amex’s expertise. Amex itself pleaded that Carey had contractual obligations to provide suitably qualified people and safe services. Those allegations linked the Ontario contracts to the claimed injuries.

The dissent also found that the Italian companies had not discharged their burden of rebuttal. Their foreign residence did not establish that the contracts’ relationship to the dispute was weak, and their expectations could not replace that inquiry. Separating related claims between countries, Jamal warned, undermined fairness, efficiency and access to justice.

The majority’s disposition nevertheless governs: the Sinclairs’ appeal was dismissed with costs throughout, leaving the stay against the three Italian companies in place. The court awarded no damages and decided no defendant’s liability for the accident.

Source: Supreme Court of Canada’s full reasons in Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo.