The Federal Court of Appeal has ordered the Canada Revenue Agency to reconsider a newcomer cook’s pandemic recovery benefits after finding that it failed to explain why his partial-year Canadian earnings should be averaged over a full year.

In Mehmeti v. Canada (Attorney General), 2026 FCA 199, decided November 17, the court set aside both the CRA’s decision and the Federal Court judgment that upheld it. The ruling requires a fresh, properly explained assessment, not an automatic finding that the benefits were payable.

A full-time job reduced to 14 hours a week

Leonard Mehmeti arrived in Canada in 2019 on a closed work permit allowing him to work only at a Burlington restaurant. He began full-time work as a cook in July, generally working 40 to 44 hours a week at $15 an hour. His Canadian gross earnings for 2019 were $15,999.

The restaurant closed when the pandemic began. After being recalled in late June 2020, he worked only 14 hours weekly until October 2021. His weekly gross pay fell from more than $600 before the pandemic to $233. He received the Canada Recovery Benefit from September 27, 2020, to October 9, 2021.

The CRA later concluded that he had not met the required 50 per cent reduction in average weekly income. Its calculation spread roughly six months of Canadian earnings across 52 weeks, lowering the comparison baseline. A statement of account required repayment of $24,417.

Reasons had to address his circumstances

The Federal Court had accepted the CRA’s approach as reasonable. The appeal court agreed that reasonableness was the governing review standard, but found that the agency’s unexplained calculation could not survive that review in this case.

The CRA’s review letter repeated the conclusion that the required income reduction was missing, without explaining why a full-year divisor was appropriate for someone who began working in Canada halfway through the year. The record did not supply the missing rationale.

Justice Mary Gleason, writing for a unanimous panel, emphasized that Mehmeti had worked to the extent legally available to him and then experienced an actual reduction of more than half his weekly earnings. His part-year Canadian residence also mattered to the income-tax context. Those circumstances required a closer assessment and a reasoned explanation.

The court did not prescribe the answer

Mehmeti asked the court to go further and hold that the CRA had to divide his earnings by the weeks he actually worked, making him eligible for the benefits. The court declined.

The legislation did not clearly prescribe the denominator for someone in his situation. Its wording could accommodate either weeks worked or a full-year period. Related employment-insurance provisions provided arguments in both directions, and a previous case about normal weekly earnings under different EI provisions did not decide this issue.

On reasonableness review, the court’s role was not to choose its preferred interpretation where more than one remained available. The CRA must now fully consider Mehmeti’s situation and explain why its calculation makes sense for him and why he is or is not entitled to the benefit. The appeal and judicial review were allowed with costs; no dollar amount for those costs was fixed.