
The Northwest Territories government has lost its appeal over CN Rail’s failure to rebuild the wildfire-damaged rail link to Hay River, with the Federal Court of Appeal finding no legal or procedural error warranting intervention.
In Northwest Territories v. Canadian National Railway Company Limited, 2026 FCA 182, the court dismissed the appeal on October 28, 2026, and fixed costs at $4,000 by agreement of the parties.
By the hearing, CN had filed formal discontinuance of the affected section. The territorial government was no longer asking for repairs and resumed operations. It instead sought a declaration that CN had breached its service obligations during the period before discontinuance.
Wildfires interrupted a northern supply route
The Meander River Subdivision runs from High Level, Alberta, through Enterprise in the Northwest Territories to Hay River. There, bulk petroleum products are transferred to barges for the territorial government’s seasonal resupply of communities along the Mackenzie River and in the Western Arctic.
Wildfires damaged parts of the line in 2023. CN repaired the approximately 269-kilometre stretch between High Level and Enterprise that autumn. But in February 2024, it told the territorial government it could not rebuild the remaining approximately 36 kilometres to Hay River without a project partner, given demand and repair costs.
Unable to find a partner, CN announced in May 2024 that it intended to discontinue the Hay River section and began the statutory process under the Canada Transportation Act.
The agency allowed the service pause to continue
The government complained to the Canadian Transportation Agency in September 2024, seeking repairs and restored service. Both sides accepted that the wildfires had suspended CN’s service obligations. Their dispute centred on how long that reasonable pause could continue.
The agency separated liability from potential remedies. In its July 30, 2025 decision, 31-R-2025, it found it reasonable that CN had not begun repairs, particularly because no traffic had been offered after the wildfire damage.
The government argued that repairs could reasonably have been completed by August 2024. The agency considered the seasonal nature of fuel shipments and the expected completion of discontinuance in November 2025. Even if traffic had been offered, it considered it unreasonable to require rebuilding for service lasting only weeks before that process ended. It dismissed the complaint and extended the pause through the transfer and discontinuance process.
Limits on the appeal were decisive
The territorial government argued that the agency had failed to apply the required balancing framework and statutory factors before extending the pause. The appeal court was not persuaded that this identified an error of law.
The underlying question was whether CN acted reasonably in not beginning repairs. The court characterized that as a factual question, or one combining facts and law, outside an appeal limited by subsection 41(1) to questions of law or jurisdiction.
The government also challenged the agency’s discontinuance timetable, arguing the process should have ended in March 2026 rather than November 2025. The court found that difference immaterial because the government acknowledged it would not have shipped fuel to Hay River during those winter months. It therefore supplied no basis for finding a service breach in that period.
Finally, the court rejected a procedural-fairness argument concerning CN’s evidence. The agency’s refusal to treat portions of CN’s answers as inadmissible or give them no weight did not establish unfairness.
The ruling leaves the agency’s case-specific decision undisturbed. It does not establish a general right for railways to abandon damaged lines without regard to statutory service obligations. Nor does it order restoration of the Hay River service: that remedy was no longer being pursued.



