The Supreme Court of Nova Scotia has upheld three Annapolis County land-use bylaw amendments, rejecting residents’ allegation that council changed the rules in bad faith to protect a disputed development.

In Green v. County of Annapolis (Municipality), 2026 NSSC 331, decided October 27, 2026, Justice Scott C. Norton dismissed the judicial review. He found council’s decision reasonable and the evidence insufficient to establish bad faith or an improper purpose.

The ruling addresses a different question from an earlier planning-board proceeding, which ended because the board lacked jurisdiction. The court examined the justification for council’s decision and the residents’ allegation about its purpose.

Changes followed a dispute over a development

The dispute arose against the background of a site-plan approval for a phased development of eleven quadplexes at Carleton Corner. Two of the applicants challenged that approval before council and then sought judicial review. That separate court proceeding was settled in February 2026.

Meanwhile, council considered a package of planning-strategy and bylaw changes. Following public information sessions, committee review and a public hearing, council approved the package on September 9, 2025. The amendments took effect on December 11.

The challenged changes allowed two main buildings on a lot, rather than one, before site-plan approval was required, subject to specifications for the second building. They also introduced townhouses and rowhouses as a permitted general land use in several zones and established specifications for them in the Mixed Use zone.

The residents separately appealed the bylaw decision to the Nova Scotia Regulatory and Appeals Board. In May 2026, the board dismissed that appeal for lack of jurisdiction.

In this judicial review, the applicants argued that the timing and combined effect of the changes showed an effort to remove an obstacle to the Carleton Corner development, avoid further regulatory scrutiny and undermine the earlier site-plan challenge. They did not challenge council’s legislative authority, procedural fairness or the amendments to the municipal planning strategy.

Council’s reasons could be found in the record

The court applied reasonableness review, recognizing the substantial discretion elected councils have when making land-use bylaws. That discretion remains bounded by the purposes of the legislation empowering them.

Councillors were not required to produce formal written reasons for passing a bylaw. The court could examine the debates, deliberations, policies and staff materials to understand the decision. Relevant social, economic and political considerations could all inform council’s choice.

Here, the staff report explained that planning rules needed to respond to population growth and housing needs, improve administrative efficiency and accommodate federal and provincial affordable-housing policies. Allowing a second main building without a minor site-plan application would also free up planning resources.

The townhouse changes gave developers more flexibility without necessarily increasing the number of permitted homes. Staff identified an inconsistency: the previous rules could permit fifteen duplexes on a lot but not ten triplexes, even though either configuration would contain thirty units.

The judge also found that the bylaw amendments implemented the planning-strategy amendments adopted by council, consistent with the Municipal Government Act. The applicants did not contend that the disputed bylaw provisions contradicted the strategy’s intent.

Suspicion did not prove an unlawful purpose

The residents relied on the cumulative effect of circumstances: an existing approval under challenge, a regulatory obstacle, changes that removed that obstacle, council’s knowledge of their objections and the fact that the earlier litigation was still pending.

The judge found that evidence insufficient. Improper purpose concerns using statutory authority for ends outside the governing legislation or considering irrelevant factors. Bad faith is a serious allegation requiring clear proof, not merely disagreement about the public interest or an adverse result.

The staff report supplied an intelligible housing and planning explanation. The applicants’ suspicions about why these particular changes were selected at that time did not establish an improper purpose. Nor did the record establish that council acted to make the earlier judicial review moot.

The court dismissed the application, leaving the amendments in place. If costs could not be agreed, the parties were invited to file written submissions by November 18, 2026. The decision is specific to this record: it does not make municipal bylaws immune from review, but illustrates why allegations of bad faith require evidence capable of displacing a legitimate planning explanation.