
Ontario’s cabinet could designate a Toronto landowner’s entire East Harbour site for transit-oriented development even though the province and the owner were still negotiating a land deal. In New Sunlight Inc. v. Ontario (Infrastructure), the Court of Appeal for Ontario upheld two cabinet orders, one removing the owner’s right to a hearing on the need for the taking and the other authorizing the province to expropriate.
New Sunlight and the province had discussed an exchange. The company would convey land needed for a priority transit project, and Ontario would permit denser development on the land the company kept. While the talks were underway, cabinet issued both orders without notifying New Sunlight.
The June 2024 order designated the company’s land as transit-oriented community land. An October order authorized Ontario to enter, take and expropriate the land for the East Harbour transit hub, the Ontario Line, a road extension, flood protection and the surrounding transit-oriented community. New Sunlight sought to have both orders quashed. The Divisional Court dismissed its application for judicial review. As that court explained, the October order gave the province authority to expropriate. Ontario later issued separate notices proposing to exercise that authority.
Why the hearing mattered
Ordinarily, an Ontario owner facing expropriation can ask the Ontario Land Tribunal to consider whether the proposed taking is fair, sound and reasonably necessary. That gives an owner a chance to argue that a smaller or different parcel would serve the project. The approving authority can proceed even if the tribunal recommends otherwise.
New Sunlight argued that the Divisional Court gave too little weight to the loss of that hearing. The appeal panel pointed to the language of the Transit-Oriented Communities Act, 2020. Cabinet may designate land that is or may be required to support a project. It did not have to establish that every part of the site was necessary before making the designation. The panel also noted the ministry’s plan to receive written comments from affected owners after notice of expropriation.
What cabinet knew
New Sunlight said cabinet had been misled because briefing notes named a neighbouring developer, Cadillac Fairview, without identifying New Sunlight as another owner. The panel found that the statute focused on the land. The notes named Cadillac Fairview because it had raised concerns about whether the province’s promise to allow denser development could be enforced. Changes to the Planning Act addressed those concerns and could also benefit New Sunlight if it reached an agreement. The designation made no distinction between owners.
The panel also rejected the argument that cabinet had authorized expropriation to give the province leverage in negotiations. The evidence supported Ontario’s explanation that it wanted a way to keep the transit project on schedule if talks failed. The question for the courts was whether the orders fell within a reasonable interpretation of cabinet’s statutory powers. The panel upheld the Divisional Court’s conclusion that they did.
The court dismissed the appeal and ordered New Sunlight to pay Ontario $15,000 in costs, all inclusive.



