
Ontario’s Divisional Court has dismissed a challenge to a warning from the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario. In Orlita v. Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario, Justice Vermette found that the tribunal had reminded Liam Orlita of an obligation he already had. It had yet to dismiss any of his applications or impose a sanction on the strength of that warning.
Orlita had filed eight applications with the tribunal. In July, an adjudicator directed that they be heard together and set a process for a preliminary hearing on whether some or all of the claims should be dismissed. Orlita asked for clarification and procedural orders. In August, the tribunal extended his deadline for submissions, addressed his accommodation request and declined to send the cases to mediation at that stage.
Orlita asked the court to set aside three paragraphs of the August endorsement. They warned that if he failed to follow the tribunal’s rules or directions, it could consider dismissing the matter as an abuse of process. The warning extended to his current and future tribunal matters. Vermette found that none of the three paragraphs decided anything. Orlita’s concern about what the tribunal might do could still be addressed if it ever acted on the warning and treated him unfairly.
The distinction mattered because courts ordinarily wait for a tribunal to finish its work before reviewing it. A danger of manifest unfairness can justify stepping in early, as can a defect so serious that the hearing would likely have to be repeated. Even a mistake in an interim ruling does not, on its own, justify immediate review. Vermette found no such exceptional circumstances here.
In a separate decision issued the same day, Vermette dismissed Orlita’s challenge to the July direction grouping the eight applications. The tribunal had extended his deadline and left other requests for the adjudicator who would hear the case. The judge found that the process still allowed any alleged unfairness to be addressed.
Vermette used Rule 2.1.01, which permits the court to dismiss a proceeding when its abusive nature is clear from the pleading itself. Orlita had received notice and made written submissions. The judge ordered no costs in either court proceeding. Both rulings left the substance of the eight human rights applications for the tribunal.



