Alberta’s information commissioner ordered Primary and Preventative Health Services to reconsider withholding old safe-consumption-policy records and include wrongly excluded material in a new response.

In Order FOIP2026-34, dated October 29, 2026, adjudicator Teresa Cunningham found insufficient evidence that a draft presentation revealed cabinet deliberations. The slides listed steps the department had already decided to take following a government review. They bore the minister’s name, but one still had a placeholder where a thought was unfinished. The department gave no date for a cabinet meeting and no evidence that cabinet received even a later version containing the same information. A shared subject was not enough to establish what cabinet had deliberated.

The dispute began with an April 2, 2020 request for safe-consumption-site policies. In Order F2021-47, dated November 30, 2021, Cunningham found Health had missed its response deadline and ordered a response. The department cited staffing pressures, request volumes and pandemic responsibilities. The adjudicator did not resolve how much each factor contributed: the issue was whether the department had answered, and it had not.

A late-2021 and early-2022 response led to review of withholding decisions. The department invoked a separate exception for pending policy or budget decisions. Cunningham distinguished unfinished work from an outstanding decision: officials could have identified a pending decision in their confidential submissions without revealing it to the applicant. They did not.

The province’s FOIP guidelines distinguish an exemption’s scope from the decision to use it. For discretionary exceptions, officials must consider the records and circumstances, including the exception’s purpose and the information’s age. The guide rejects blanket non-disclosure policies. For advice records, the separate discretionary assessment considers whether disclosure would impede future candid advice, frank deliberation or policy-making.

The applicant pointed to a draft literature review as an example of background material. Cunningham found that the way the department had presented factual information to support policy proposals made it analysis. Other passages would reveal officials’ deliberations. Both could qualify for protection, but that still left the question of whether withholding each passage would protect candid discussion six years later. The department had explained the purpose of the exceptions without explaining its decisions about particular redactions. Reconsideration must address each item’s age, nature and continuing need for protection. Records were at least six years old.

Cunningham agreed with the department that merely mentioning a consumption site did not bring an email within the request. Three pages of emails in the third package did more than mention sites: they directed the course of future policy work. They qualified even under the department’s own reading of the request. Nor had the applicant narrowed the request by identifying particular records he hoped to receive.

New exemptions remain possible; this was not an order releasing everything. Compliance must be reported within 50 days after receipt.

The commissioner’s transitional guidance says access requests made before Alberta’s replacement legislation took effect continue under the former Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.