
B.C.’s information commissioner’s office refused to let Islands Trust disregard part of an access request about Bowen Island vineyard and winery bylaws.
In Order F26-93, dated October 28, Adjudicator Carol Pakkala found that the Trust had not proved unreasonable operational interference or excessive breadth under section 43 of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.
The disputed request sought the origin, history and removal of vineyard provisions without a date limit. The Trust argued that searching decades of records would disrupt operations, but supplied no affidavit evidence or meaningful estimates of staff time, costs or record volume.
Its claim of a 50-year search also conflicted with its statement that pre-1999 planning records had gone to the municipality. A long timeframe alone was insufficient.
The request identified a particular bylaw and subject. Its lack of dates was reasonable because the requester did not know when the provisions originated.
The ruling denied permission to disregard the request; it did not decide which responsive records must ultimately be disclosed.



